Teach the new kid
on pve i would say anything works, even with no armor…..
on WvW if u dont have DH, run a traditional meditation build mayyyybeee with rune of durability.
I know of one guard in particular who doesn’t play DH and runs scepter/sh. S/he does pretty well and definitely fills that tank role. In wvw, having a melee weapon or melee set is great but I highly recommend pairing it with either staff for group support, or a ranged weapon such as scepter.
If you like being a tank and supporting allies you might be able to get away with m/sh and sc/f in small group setting in wvw. That’s just about the most defensive weapon set duo I can think of. For 1v1 or solo, this build won’t be very effective. Half the fun is theory crafting the build so knock yourself out!