Membrane + Staff regen. Get it back?

Membrane + Staff regen. Get it back?

in Mesmer

Posted by: Daishi.6027

Daishi.6027

Hey I was curios on Staff 1 We used to have it proc regeneration during the beta and with a trait like iMembrane it was pretty broken. Do you guys think that it being nerfed to a (imo) Fair c/d may be opening more options and the potential reinstatement of Regen on staff bounces, come feb?

Personally I think it would be nice to have more support options in PvE, and don’t think it’d be all that broken in PvP.

Thoughts?

“I control time and space; you can’t break free.~”
“Maybe I was the illusion all along!”

Membrane + Staff regen. Get it back?

in Mesmer

Posted by: Dastion.3106

Dastion.3106

It wasn’t OP because it inflicted ANY boon or condition, so the odds of getting a lot of regen were slim even with clones.

The removal of regen wasn’t because of membrane, it was because the Staff’s randomness was a detriment which made it unreliable. So they tightened up the potential random effects to themes. Winds of Chaos does offensive conditions/boons, Chaos Armor does boons and conditions which protect or otherwise help get the target off you, and Chaos Storm is control and protection – that’s not a perfect description of each skill’s role but you see what I mean. The tighter themed randomness gave our skills a focus.

Prior to that the skills were literally all the exact same effect with a different delivery method.

Membrane + Staff regen. Get it back?

in Mesmer

Posted by: Mere Image.8376

Mere Image.8376

I would love to see them taking away the 15 second restriction.

Server: Ehmry Bay
Guild: Commanders of the Reborn Empire Nation [CORE]
Level 80 Professions: Mesmer, Warrior, Thief

Membrane + Staff regen. Get it back?

in Mesmer

Posted by: Nuka Cola.8520

Nuka Cola.8520

Before doing anything to staff THEY MUST REMOVE THE STUPID VULNERABILITY ON WINDS OF CHAOS. Then it will be half decent for dps and they can do whatever with it.

Fact: every Thief tells you to “l2p” when the subject is to nerf stealth.

Membrane + Staff regen. Get it back?

in Mesmer

Posted by: Hiki.9310

Hiki.9310

Before doing anything to staff THEY MUST REMOVE THE STUPID VULNERABILITY ON WINDS OF CHAOS. Then it will be half decent for dps and they can do whatever with it.

I believe the staff was meant to be balanced with the vulnerability on auto attack but only under the assumption that the trait illusionary elasticity would be working for our illusions. If they ever took the vulnerability off and fixed this bugged trait the staff auto attack from the mesmer and clones would be putting out at least 6 stacks of bleeding in the first barrage. All that needs to be done is a fix to make the bounce trait work and the staff would be more than just fine.

“If it ain’t broke don’t fix it” – Mallyx

Membrane + Staff regen. Get it back?

in Mesmer

Posted by: RuneValkyrie.3672

RuneValkyrie.3672

Before doing anything to staff THEY MUST REMOVE THE STUPID VULNERABILITY ON WINDS OF CHAOS. Then it will be half decent for dps and they can do whatever with it.

I believe the staff was meant to be balanced with the vulnerability on auto attack but only under the assumption that the trait illusionary elasticity would be working for our illusions. If they ever took the vulnerability off and fixed this bugged trait the staff auto attack from the mesmer and clones would be putting out at least 6 stacks of bleeding in the first barrage. All that needs to be done is a fix to make the bounce trait work and the staff would be more than just fine.

I agree with everything you said. If they were to take off the invulnerability of Wind of Chaos then its understandable for llusionary elasticity not to apply to your staff clones anyone would understand how unbalance is that. But the way that is working now is so underwhelming compare to other classes. On top of needing the trait to work for your clones we also need to speed up the animation is very very slow compare to other ranged weapons and this adjustment will sill not be OP. Now in the other hand the way it was in beta where clones and yourself had bounce 3 well… that was OP.

Membrane + Staff regen. Get it back?

in Mesmer

Posted by: Embolism.8106

Embolism.8106

IMO the Staff’s DPS is already quite potent with WoC + IE + 3 Staff Clones, especially considering how tough condition Mesmer builds are. While I would like WoC to not deal negligible damage 1/3 of the time, taking that away may cause the Staff to become OP.