Guild Wars 2

Folks, please consolidate feedback into one thread. I know everybody wants to create their own feedback thread. But it makes it harder for Robert Gee to read them when they’re spread everywhere. Please consolidate feedback to make it easier for the devs to collect data and feedback. This is to make sure feedback is read, so win/win for everybody.

And no, I have no idea which thread to be marked as “the” feedback thread. There are already 5+ feedback threads, some already on the 2nd page.

I don’t mean to make my thread “the” consolidated thread lol.

gavyne.6847:

I don’t mean to make my thread “the” consolidated thread lol.

oh.

The problem is everybody thinks theirs is special enough to make its own thread (I sure as hell think mine is special), and then that thread generally becomes a discussion of that particular feedback. With one consolidated thread it makes it really hard to track 5+ individual conversations about 5+ completely different feedbacks.

Maybe have a compilation thread that provides links to other threads of different discussions for Reaper feedback?

1 Thread for feedback and reasoning only and 1 Thread for discussions.

The point of a consolidated thread is to tell ROBERT what the issues we think the reaper has. Not to argue or debate with each other, so trying to keep track of the debate is useless.

Feedback thread is for robert and not for us to argue our mundane point of view because ultimate he decides NOT us. This is not a design committee

Discussion provides far better information to work with 50 different checklists of changes. It allows people to challenge changes, for informed backup to be given, for ideas to be expanded on and refined. Otherwise you end up with everyone just spewing their first idea without being able to fully define what they want, why, and give reason.