How much regen is too much?

How much regen is too much?

in Ranger

Posted by: jaif.3518

jaif.3518

I’ve put together a wvw ranger build for 80 using shouts:

http://gw2skills.net/editor/?fMMQRAsf3YnAVkFcXQWBhaZAp9ITsEM5VYWcPGlOJET5TbgtVA-jECBYiDimWAmEAk8IQZQFRjtupIas6ZER1qbYxAwE-w

I’m 70ish right now, and playing something pretty close, and found my survivability to be very strong, except conditions (esp immobilize) are a pain. I’m still missing empathic bond, and I’m not eating my lemongrass soup yet (I wait for 80 before I equip myself seriously), but I’m still wondering if that will be enough at 80.

Since all my shouts give me regen, and guard can theoretically keep regen up permanently, would it be reasonable to switch dwayna runes for melandru runes? I’m concerned, because in practice I’m certainly not using guard the moment it comes up in a fight, so I know I’ll miss some regeneration.

Bonus question: I’ve really lost as to what pet to use in this build. I’ve tried a bunch, and settled on ranged pets for now as I think they bring the most DPS to the table against the human bunny rabbits that you find in WvW. But I’m also looking at the forum-favorite dog&wolf, and maybe the chill pets.

-Jeff

How much regen is too much?

in Ranger

Posted by: Coarr.3286

Coarr.3286

[care] Coarr Ix – Ranger
Kodash
Stomp some Piken!

How much regen is too much?

in Ranger

Posted by: denimdan.8642

denimdan.8642

its a waste to use 6 dwayna runes with this build as it gives you extra regen that you dont need.
Use, 2 traveler, 2 monk, and 2 water all superior, use a war horn and you will have perma regen, swift, fury and might for you and 4 others. you get the same survivabilty with a dps boost as well and you give even more support with the extra boons

I run a vary similar build to yours but with power, toughness, healing power gear and i used to run the same runes, but trust me when you switch to these runes and a war horn you will notice an increase to the amount you help your party and your dps

Ranger
Storm Bluff Isle [EVOH]

(edited by denimdan.8642)

How much regen is too much?

in Ranger

Posted by: Coarr.3286

Coarr.3286

its a waste to use 6 dwayna runes with this build as it gives you extra regen that you dont need.
Use, 2 traveler, 2 monk, and 2 water all superior, use a war horn and you will have perma regen, swift, fury and might for you and 4 others. you get the same survivabilty with a dps boost as well and you give even more support with the extra boons

you could have simply quote my post

[care] Coarr Ix – Ranger
Kodash
Stomp some Piken!

How much regen is too much?

in Ranger

Posted by: denimdan.8642

denimdan.8642

its a waste to use 6 dwayna runes with this build as it gives you extra regen that you dont need.
Use, 2 traveler, 2 monk, and 2 water all superior, use a war horn and you will have perma regen, swift, fury and might for you and 4 others. you get the same survivabilty with a dps boost as well and you give even more support with the extra boons

you could have simply quote my post

lol yea i didn’t see your second build until after i posted mine, my bad :P

Ranger
Storm Bluff Isle [EVOH]

How much regen is too much?

in Ranger

Posted by: McWolfy.5924

McWolfy.5924

regen is one of the weakest buffs in game. slow and low heal. most classes have it. we, rangers use it only in spvp because we have 4 sources of regen or regen kitten abilitys. with dodges and evaids we can survive most 1v1 situations and slowly condy pressure the enemy. and this is why its not working in pve and wvw. there u need fast kills and big, insta heals.

WSR→Piken→Deso→Piken→FSP→Deso
Just the WvW
R3200+

How much regen is too much?

in Ranger

Posted by: sminkiottone.6972

sminkiottone.6972

regen is one of the weakest buffs in game. slow and low heal. most classes have it. we, rangers use it only in spvp because we have 4 sources of regen or regen kitten abilitys. with dodges and evaids we can survive most 1v1 situations and slowly condy pressure the enemy. and this is why its not working in pve and wvw. there u need fast kills and big, insta heals.

Imo you are wrong, yes regen is slow, but it’s steady and if you trait right you can reach almost 100% regen uptime in a fight, with +1500 healing power you can heal +1k HP every second, not weak at all.

Sure you need 3k+ toughness, and some evades for the bursts, but if you play smart you can win almost every fight ( even 1vs2 ).

In a zerg fight ? not that important, but it can outheal almost every condition, never happened to die from bleed or burn ? with regen you wont !

How much regen is too much?

in Ranger

Posted by: denimdan.8642

denimdan.8642

regen is one of the weakest buffs in game. slow and low heal. most classes have it. we, rangers use it only in spvp because we have 4 sources of regen or regen kitten abilitys. with dodges and evaids we can survive most 1v1 situations and slowly condy pressure the enemy. and this is why its not working in pve and wvw. there u need fast kills and big, insta heals.

have you ever had a fight in wvw where they had necros ripping your zergs boons? stability and might mean nothing if you don’t have boons to cover them from being ripped. while regen and swift may be weak boons, there at the top of the priority list when it comes to what boon gets ripped first. haveing a few guys that can constantly throw up 4 boons on 4 guys each makes if very difficult for the enemy to get to your stabilty

Ranger
Storm Bluff Isle [EVOH]

How much regen is too much?

in Ranger

Posted by: Boreal.9826

Boreal.9826

regen is one of the weakest buffs in game. slow and low heal. most classes have it. we, rangers use it only in spvp because we have 4 sources of regen or regen kitten abilitys. with dodges and evaids we can survive most 1v1 situations and slowly condy pressure the enemy. and this is why its not working in pve and wvw. there u need fast kills and big, insta heals.

have you ever had a fight in wvw where they had necros ripping your zergs boons? stability and might mean nothing if you don’t have boons to cover them from being ripped. while regen and swift may be weak boons, there at the top of the priority list when it comes to what boon gets ripped first. haveing a few guys that can constantly throw up 4 boons on 4 guys each makes if very difficult for the enemy to get to your stabilty

Exactly. As a Nature’s Voice spammer, this boon (ahem, stability) protection is one of my primary contributions to my frontline teammates. Well that, and providing the best water field (despite nerf) in the game on command.

It ain’t much, but at least it’s something.

How much regen is too much?

in Ranger

Posted by: denimdan.8642

denimdan.8642

regen is one of the weakest buffs in game. slow and low heal. most classes have it. we, rangers use it only in spvp because we have 4 sources of regen or regen kitten abilitys. with dodges and evaids we can survive most 1v1 situations and slowly condy pressure the enemy. and this is why its not working in pve and wvw. there u need fast kills and big, insta heals.

have you ever had a fight in wvw where they had necros ripping your zergs boons? stability and might mean nothing if you don’t have boons to cover them from being ripped. while regen and swift may be weak boons, there at the top of the priority list when it comes to what boon gets ripped first. haveing a few guys that can constantly throw up 4 boons on 4 guys each makes if very difficult for the enemy to get to your stabilty

Exactly. As a Nature’s Voice spammer, this boon (ahem, stability) protection is one of my primary contributions to my frontline teammates. Well that, and providing the best water field (despite nerf) in the game on command.

It ain’t much, but at least it’s something.

i havent looked very far into it, but with the current meta for the builds of zergs/hammer trains. I don’t believe any other class can reapply these duration for regen and swiftness as fast as a ranger, with 15 sec of it on a 12 sec cd, as well as up to 4 other ways to apply them as soon as it gets ripped we are able to re apply before the next boon rip hits, and that along with the abilty to survive just as long as a war/guard in the middle of the fight, gives ranger the potential to be the best defense against boon stripping short of killing all necros asap.

Ranger
Storm Bluff Isle [EVOH]

How much regen is too much?

in Ranger

Posted by: ChillyChinaman.6057

ChillyChinaman.6057

regen is one of the weakest buffs in game. slow and low heal. most classes have it. we, rangers use it only in spvp because we have 4 sources of regen or regen kitten abilitys. with dodges and evaids we can survive most 1v1 situations and slowly condy pressure the enemy. and this is why its not working in pve and wvw. there u need fast kills and big, insta heals.

have you ever had a fight in wvw where they had necros ripping your zergs boons? stability and might mean nothing if you don’t have boons to cover them from being ripped. while regen and swift may be weak boons, there at the top of the priority list when it comes to what boon gets ripped first. haveing a few guys that can constantly throw up 4 boons on 4 guys each makes if very difficult for the enemy to get to your stabilty

Exactly. As a Nature’s Voice spammer, this boon (ahem, stability) protection is one of my primary contributions to my frontline teammates. Well that, and providing the best water field (despite nerf) in the game on command.

It ain’t much, but at least it’s something.

i havent looked very far into it, but with the current meta for the builds of zergs/hammer trains. I don’t believe any other class can reapply these duration for regen and swiftness as fast as a ranger, with 15 sec of it on a 12 sec cd, as well as up to 4 other ways to apply them as soon as it gets ripped we are able to re apply before the next boon rip hits, and that along with the abilty to survive just as long as a war/guard in the middle of the fight, gives ranger the potential to be the best defense against boon stripping short of killing all necros asap.

Fair point, it is something that Ranger can do. However, it is a thankless job and not as fun as doing something else.

How much regen is too much?

in Ranger

Posted by: Sanduskel.1850

Sanduskel.1850

Do the boon durations stack? Also, do they increase the length of swiftness and regen effects from natures voice?

OP’d thief, lol

How much regen is too much?

in Ranger

Posted by: Boreal.9826

Boreal.9826

Yes, increased boon duration affects swiftness and regen from Nature’s Voice. From what I can tell, this is based on the recipient’s stats and not the giver’s.

Which is unfortunate for me, given that I’m running at about +80% boon duration. :/

How much regen is too much?

in Ranger

Posted by: Sanduskel.1850

Sanduskel.1850

Yes, increased boon duration affects swiftness and regen from Nature’s Voice. From what I can tell, this is based on the recipient’s stats and not the giver’s.

Which is unfortunate for me, given that I’m running at about +80% boon duration. :/

But you benefit from the shout as well, correct?

OP’d thief, lol

How much regen is too much?

in Ranger

Posted by: Boreal.9826

Boreal.9826

Yes, increased boon duration affects swiftness and regen from Nature’s Voice. From what I can tell, this is based on the recipient’s stats and not the giver’s.

Which is unfortunate for me, given that I’m running at about +80% boon duration. :/

But you benefit from the shout as well, correct?

Yep, with my boon duration plus traits, I build my regen up to well over a minute and swiftness to about half of that while out of combat. I’m always spamming Guard.

How much regen is too much?

in Ranger

Posted by: Sanduskel.1850

Sanduskel.1850

Last question. I assume you lose zero regen effect by not using Dwayna runes, replacing that lost regen with the boon/shout effects.

OP’d thief, lol

How much regen is too much?

in Ranger

Posted by: Boreal.9826

Boreal.9826

I used to run full dwayna runes, which was ok.

Switching to a mix of runes for boon duration loses some regen (doesn’t matter because you have plenty already) and healing power, but you gain oh so much more. Most noteworthy are the longer lasting protection boon (via dodge rolling and Nature’s Protection) and the Rampage as One buff for almost 40 seconds! Such long lasting stability and fury, “protected” from stripping by swiftness and regen (easily reapplied by shouting again) is pretty dang awesomesauce for frontline Rangers.

(edited by Boreal.9826)

How much regen is too much?

in Ranger

Posted by: denimdan.8642

denimdan.8642

Yes, increased boon duration affects swiftness and regen from Nature’s Voice. From what I can tell, this is based on the recipient’s stats and not the giver’s.

Which is unfortunate for me, given that I’m running at about +80% boon duration. :/

incorerect…when it comes to natures voice the boons you give to others last just as long as the do on you…if it last 17 sec on you, then it will last 17 sec on the ppl you put it on. with the 33% regen duration in crease from traits being the exception (that increase is use less with this build any way lol)

Ranger
Storm Bluff Isle [EVOH]

How much regen is too much?

in Ranger

Posted by: denimdan.8642

denimdan.8642

Last question. I assume you lose zero regen effect by not using Dwayna runes, replacing that lost regen with the boon/shout effects.

this is correct with teh runes i mentioned i have 80% boon duration witch gets natures voices to 18 sec per shout, RaO to about 38 sec, and call of the wild to be about 28 sec

Ranger
Storm Bluff Isle [EVOH]

How much regen is too much?

in Ranger

Posted by: Boreal.9826

Boreal.9826

Yes, increased boon duration affects swiftness and regen from Nature’s Voice. From what I can tell, this is based on the recipient’s stats and not the giver’s.

Which is unfortunate for me, given that I’m running at about +80% boon duration. :/

incorerect…when it comes to natures voice the boons you give to others last just as long as the do on you…if it last 17 sec on you, then it will last 17 sec on the ppl you put it on. with the 33% regen duration in crease from traits being the exception (that increase is use less with this build any way lol)

Are you certain? When I’m traveling with my group I am pretty sure that my buffs drop off them earlier than off of me. I don’t use the 33% regen trait anymore, since I don’t really need it.

I’ll have to test it again tonight.

How much regen is too much?

in Ranger

Posted by: denimdan.8642

denimdan.8642

Yes, increased boon duration affects swiftness and regen from Nature’s Voice. From what I can tell, this is based on the recipient’s stats and not the giver’s.

Which is unfortunate for me, given that I’m running at about +80% boon duration. :/

incorerect…when it comes to natures voice the boons you give to others last just as long as the do on you…if it last 17 sec on you, then it will last 17 sec on the ppl you put it on. with the 33% regen duration in crease from traits being the exception (that increase is use less with this build any way lol)

Are you certain? When I’m traveling with my group I am pretty sure that my buffs drop off them earlier than off of me. I don’t use the 33% regen trait anymore, since I don’t really need it.

I’ll have to test it again tonight.

nature voices has a very limited range (360) about the size of guard ring, when you see it fall off early its because they didnt get one of your hits from guard(the radius is off of you not the ring

last i checked, i was giving full duration to every one, but this was before latest patch…i have ran this build for a long time and i cant bring my self to switch lol

Ranger
Storm Bluff Isle [EVOH]

(edited by denimdan.8642)

How much regen is too much?

in Ranger

Posted by: Boreal.9826

Boreal.9826

Yes, increased boon duration affects swiftness and regen from Nature’s Voice. From what I can tell, this is based on the recipient’s stats and not the giver’s.

Which is unfortunate for me, given that I’m running at about +80% boon duration. :/

incorerect…when it comes to natures voice the boons you give to others last just as long as the do on you…if it last 17 sec on you, then it will last 17 sec on the ppl you put it on. with the 33% regen duration in crease from traits being the exception (that increase is use less with this build any way lol)

Are you certain? When I’m traveling with my group I am pretty sure that my buffs drop off them earlier than off of me. I don’t use the 33% regen trait anymore, since I don’t really need it.

I’ll have to test it again tonight.

nature voices has a very limited range (360) about the size of guard ring, when you see it fall off early its because they didnt get one of your hits from guard(the radius is off of you not the ring

last i checked, i was giving full duration to every one, but this was before latest patch…i have ran this build for a long time and i cant bring my self to switch lol

Well… that’s great news to me! It’s only fair that boons are calculated from the giver’s stats.

Likewise, I’ve ran this build for a long time. Since the introduction of Nature’s Voice, and I can’t switch either. I love it!

How much regen is too much?

in Ranger

Posted by: denimdan.8642

denimdan.8642

Yes, increased boon duration affects swiftness and regen from Nature’s Voice. From what I can tell, this is based on the recipient’s stats and not the giver’s.

Which is unfortunate for me, given that I’m running at about +80% boon duration. :/

incorerect…when it comes to natures voice the boons you give to others last just as long as the do on you…if it last 17 sec on you, then it will last 17 sec on the ppl you put it on. with the 33% regen duration in crease from traits being the exception (that increase is use less with this build any way lol)

Are you certain? When I’m traveling with my group I am pretty sure that my buffs drop off them earlier than off of me. I don’t use the 33% regen trait anymore, since I don’t really need it.

I’ll have to test it again tonight.

nature voices has a very limited range (360) about the size of guard ring, when you see it fall off early its because they didnt get one of your hits from guard(the radius is off of you not the ring

last i checked, i was giving full duration to every one, but this was before latest patch…i have ran this build for a long time and i cant bring my self to switch lol

Well… that’s great news to me! It’s only fair that boons are calculated from the giver’s stats.

Likewise, I’ve ran this build for a long time. Since the introduction of Nature’s Voice, and I can’t switch either. I love it!

yea it feels good to have found a build that actualy contributes to blob fights/organised guild groups…boon covers may not seem important, until you run into a anti hammer train necro group

Ranger
Storm Bluff Isle [EVOH]

How much regen is too much?

in Ranger

Posted by: Chopps.5047

Chopps.5047

This is an odd question to me. If you are playing regen ranger, regen should basically always be up while in combat, right? Isn’t the more relevant question:how much healing power do you need? Should the ranger play the signet of the wild or fortifying bond for the pet heals? Should the ranger go magi for crits that activate companion’s might? Should the ranger use troll and rely on bear for condition removal?

Anyone have any ideas about that stuff? Just a few of things I have wondered.

Tin Foil Hat Hearer »—> Ranger Extraordinaire »—> “Be like water…”

How much regen is too much?

in Ranger

Posted by: denimdan.8642

denimdan.8642

This is an odd question to me. If you are playing regen ranger, regen should basically always be up while in combat, right? Isn’t the more relevant question:how much healing power do you need? Should the ranger play the signet of the wild or fortifying bond for the pet heals? Should the ranger go magi for crits that activate companion’s might? Should the ranger use troll and rely on bear for condition removal?

Anyone have any ideas about that stuff? Just a few of things I have wondered.

IF you run shouts, you only need one skill “Guard” to keep perma regen up.

i currently have 1.1k healing power with clerics gear and do about 278 regen tics (i can get it to about 320 with food).

fortifying bond auto comes with the shout build, i run signet of wild for the extra 150 tics of healing to supplement my regen but swap it for renewal when i feel the need.(if you run shouts your pet gets perma protection along with the regen so it almost never dies)

id rather have my pet alive to do dmg than risk losing his dmg entirely (as well as my codi removal) so i dont run the companions might (im also hearing that its bugging alot)

as for the condi removal. i ALWAYS recommend running empathetic bond, if you dont codis WILL screw you over…that being said troll heals for alot more(1008 h/s in my build), so for small groups i run troll, for organised/zergs i run healing spring as it is the best water field in the game

This is coming from a person that runs a shout build, there are other regen builds that are not near as tanky but output significantly more dps(no other build has perma regen other than shouts atm)
hope this anwsers your questions

Ranger
Storm Bluff Isle [EVOH]

(edited by denimdan.8642)