Toughness/Vit/Power gear in WvW
For me the WvW armor set is pretty good in terms of survivability. I am currently running with power/vitality/toughness armor set with divinity runes but with berserker accessories, amulet and rings along with the exquisite ruby on them.
I was a full dps build but ran into some 3 hit combos from warriors and thieves alike that I decided to put some survivability into my armor set. From my experience, what I lost from dps, I gained in staying alive. I can fight 1v1 and 2v1 situations where I know as a dps build I could not. Also trying to run away from a big group just got better knowing you can take a hit while waiting for that 1 sec before your cooldown will refresh.
Rethesis
See my experiences are just the opposite of yours. I barely notice any increased survivability with this set. It might be that my traits spec is more designed for high burst, was hoping some back stab rogues would weigh in on their gear and what they prefer.