(edited by Caithe.5314)
Cannot complete 'Every Piece Matters'
Even if you “dropped” the item there should still be an item in your inventory. Unless you dragged the item out of your inventory and destroyed it of course. You could try putting the item in your bank(assuming you didn’t destroy it) and try talking to Ellen again.
it was not in my inventory, my Inventory was full when i entered and Ellen still just talks to me about the clues.