Guild Wars 2

I am in five guilds which are level 0, level 11, level 21, level 28, and level 31.

Lvl 0 and 11 obviously do not have resource nodes yet. Lvl 21, 28, and 31 should.

However for last one and half weeks, maybe a bit more, whenever I attempt to gather resources from those three guilds the following usually happen:

LvL 21 – No problem, could gather from all five nodes.
Lvl 28 – There are five nodes present but they do not have anything for me to harvest although other guildmates confirmed they were able to harvest from this guild’s nodes
Lvl 31 – There are five nodes present but only four offer resources for me to harvest

I made sure I was representing each respective guild before entering and visiting its resource nodes. Some people suggested it’s a bugged instance and I have to wait a while then try again in order to get into a new instance. This hasn’t worked for me. I even switched characters and rechecked – again, nothing.

Am I missing anything? I checked whether if a guild could deny access to nodes to certain members (similar to guild permissions to withdraw and deposit items into guild bank tabs, etc) and from what I understood, there’s no such thing.

So what is going on?

uh oh i think i messed up somehow

EDIT: oh well here are screencaps of each GH I attempted to gather from.

Update:

December 7:
Guild 31 – all nodes there
Guild 28 – all nodes except for lumber there
Guild 21 – nothing although node bases are present

December 8
Guild 31 – all nodes there
Guild 28 – all nodes except for lumber there
Guild 21 – nothing although node bases are present

Anybody else experiencing this as well? Or am I just cursed?

These nodes are once per account per day. No matter how many guilds.
Does guild of level 28 have the lumber node unlocked? If not, that’s why.

However, these nodes are bugged, we’ve upgraded ours to give more, yet only the mining node does by 1. And they still only ouput copper/green wood, when we should be getting other mats too.

Haleydawn.3764:

These nodes are once per account per day. No matter how many guilds.
Does guild of level 28 have the lumber node unlocked? If not, that’s why.

However, these nodes are bugged, we’ve upgraded ours to give more, yet only the mining node does by 1. And they still only ouput copper/green wood, when we should be getting other mats too.

Thanks for the response. From what I understood, GH nodes are once per account per day per each guild hall (provided that they have necessary upgrades in the place, of course).

Perhaps you are correct, it’s once per day regardless of how many guild halls. I just would like to get a clarification from Anet on what is the expected behavior so I can determine what is appropriate and what is bugged.

Furthermore, keep in the mind, in the OP thread it was:

LvL 21 – All five nodes there, could harvest
Lvl 28 – Couldn’t harvest anything even although there are nodes present
Lvl 31 – There are five nodes present but only four offer resources for me to harvest

Yet on next two days I decided to change the order of harvest:
Guild 31 – all nodes there
Guild 28 – all nodes except for lumber there
Guild 21 – nothing although node bases are present

So on the first day I recorded this, I couldn’t harvest anything from Guild 28 but I was able to harvest four out of five nodes on second and third days. Also, guildmates from that guild confirmed they were able to harvest lumber while I wasn’t able to do so even if I was repping that guild in their guild hall.

You need to identify the level of each node for each guild. If I understand correctly, you’re only supposed to be able to harvest one of each type per day. However, it’s currently bugged so you can harvest different level nodes, if present in the different guild halls.

I’ve been able to do this consistently and it ends whenever the nodes are upgraded to be the same level. So, for example, let’s say it’s

• Guild A: Ore level 1, Wood level 1
• Guild B: Ore level 2, Wood level 2

I’d be able to get four harvests/day visiting both guilds. When ‘A’ upgrades Ore to L2, then I get 3/day, until B upgrades Ore to L3, at which point I get 4/day again.

In other words, the current mechanic (intended or bugged) is: harvest one node of each type of each level per day, regardless of how many guild halls include the node.

Illconceived Was Na.9781:

You need to identify the level of each node for each guild. If I understand correctly, you’re only supposed to be able to harvest one of each type per day. However, it’s currently bugged so you can harvest different level nodes, if present in the different guild halls.

I’ve been able to do this consistently and it ends whenever the nodes are upgraded to be the same level. So, for example, let’s say it’s

• Guild A: Ore level 1, Wood level 1
• Guild B: Ore level 2, Wood level 2

I’d be able to get four harvests/day visiting both guilds. When ‘A’ upgrades Ore to L2, then I get 3/day, until B upgrades Ore to L3, at which point I get 4/day again.

In other words, the current mechanic (intended or bugged) is: harvest one node of each type of each level per day, regardless of how many guild halls include the node.

Interesting – how do I identify level of nodes?

Yesterday I changed the order of harvesting so its currently:

Dec 6:
LvL 21 – All five nodes there, could harvest
Lvl 28 – Couldn’t harvest anything even although there are nodes present
Lvl 31 – There are five nodes present but only four offer resources for me to harvest

Dec 7 & 8:
Guild 31 – all nodes there
Guild 28 – all nodes except for lumber there
Guild 21 – nothing although node bases are present

Dec 9:
Guild 28: All nodes there
Guild 22: Node bases there but 0 harvest
Guild 31: All nodes harvested except for lumber which was empty

Dec 6:
LvL 21 – All five nodes there, could harvest
Lvl 28 – Couldn’t harvest anything even although there are nodes present
Lvl 31 – There are five nodes present but only four offer resources for me to harvest

Dec 7 & 8:
Guild 31 – all nodes there
Guild 28 – all nodes except for lumber there
Guild 21 – nothing although node bases are present

Dec 9:
Guild 28: All nodes there
Guild 22: Node bases there but 0 harvest
Guild 31: All nodes harvested except for lumber which was empty

Dec 10:
Guild 28: all
Guild 33: all except for lumber
Guild 23: nothing

Barinthus.8347:

Illconceived Was Na.9781:

You need to identify the level of each node for each guild. If I understand correctly, you’re only supposed to be able to harvest one of each type per day. However, it’s currently bugged so you can harvest different level nodes, if present in the different guild halls.

I’ve been able to do this consistently and it ends whenever the nodes are upgraded to be the same level. So, for example, let’s say it’s

• Guild A: Ore level 1, Wood level 1
• Guild B: Ore level 2, Wood level 2

I’d be able to get four harvests/day visiting both guilds. When ‘A’ upgrades Ore to L2, then I get 3/day, until B upgrades Ore to L3, at which point I get 4/day again.

In other words, the current mechanic (intended or bugged) is: harvest one node of each type of each level per day, regardless of how many guild halls include the node.

Interesting – how do I identify level of nodes?

Talk to the workshop NPC and look at which are unlocked.

Khisanth.2948:

Talk to the workshop NPC and look at which are unlocked.

Thanks, will try this.

Also would appreciate a response from the support confirming or whatever that this is the intended behavior or not.