Guild Wars 2

I couldn’t see a place for feature requests, so here it is. Having the “Kick from guild” option in the party window is just an accident waiting to happen. I have never intentionally kicked anyone from the guild within the party window, but I have done it twice now accidentally. Please move this option onto the guild panel only.

Thanks,

A guy in my guild has kicked several people from the guild this way. We’ve just taken to calling him an evil overlord.

Haha, I second this so badly. I’ve kicked one of our member like 4 times already. Must agree that it’s a poor UI, especially when you’re trying to join a guildie on another map and the option itself is placed right above the Kick from guild button.

There should be atleast at confirmation: “Do you want to kick that person?”.

Dorid.1793:

There should be atleast at confirmation: “Do you want to kick that person?”.

Maybe not — a lot of guilds purge inactive members once a month; this would slow them down a lot (and get them to stop paying attention to the message).

Removing the option from friends list and party menu would be a great start.

Then maybe for guild leaders there could be a button on the roster that is something like: “show everyone who hasn’t logged on and/or hasn’t gained any achievement points since year-month-day” and if that’s selected, then there’s no warning dialogue that you are about to kick.

Once both of those are done, then add a confirmation message before kicking someone in any other context.

Same thing with “Join in [map]”: http://www.reddit.com/r/Guildwars2/comments/279bpk/i_think_the_guy_who_put_join_in_server_next_to/

I believe guild functionality should only belong to the guild panel.