Guild Wars 2

Er, wait, so…

You had your ‘dagger’ and two weapons.

You transmuted the ’dagger’’s appearance on to the first weapon. Then you transmuted that again on to the second?

So, by the sound of it, it’s working correctly unless I totally misread. When you transmute two items together, you only get one item. So if you wanted two priory daggers, you needed two tokens.

You need to read up on how Transmutation stones work.

Here’s a basic rundown:
-You use the Stone and put 2 weapons in the slots on the menu.
-You select the top items, which determine the looks of the weapon.
-You select the middle items, which determine the stats.
-You select the bottom items, which determine the bonuses/sigils/upgrades.
-Click Transmute, and you have an entirely new weapon.

It’s a lot like Thunderdome. Two weapons enter, one weapon leaves. I’m sorry you lost your Exotic, but that’s how Transmutation stones work and you have no one to blame but yourself for not reading up.