Guild Wars 2

The copper sickle says it is used to harvest carrots, which is generally true, carrots being level 1-25 nodes. But the carrots in the Dry Top oasis can not be harvested with a steel sickle, although they should. Mithril and orichalcum sickles work, I haven’t tried copper, iron or darksteel.

Carrots can also come from variegated taproots (level 40 to 60) as well as taproots (15 to 40). Since Dry Top is a level 80 zone, they most likely required mithril or orichalcum tools regardless of how they are named. (Possibly the nodes are misnamed. Or possibly those are the new level 80 carrot nodes).

The nodes are named ‘carrots’ and drop only carrots, so they aren’t misnamed variegated taproots nodes but actual carrot nodes. As such, I maintain that they should be harvestable with any sickle. Especially because the cabbage and lettuce nodes in the oasis are harvestable with the appropriate sickles.