Guild Wars 2

Our guild “The Mailed Fist” [FIST] had a sucessful guild challenge run after 1 failed attempt. We got the branded ogre challenge and succeeded. Each of us got our commendations and weekly loot but sadly the 30 merits were not counted into our guild window and the guild mission tab says that the quest is still active

How come its not counted in yet? Can you guys please fix it and maybe at least give us those 30 merits? We worked hard for it and I think you have logs of these stuff since it is reflected in the Guild missions history.

Fire meets Ice [fmi] had thing happen with Scratch Sentry Defense Guild challenge. players got reward but guild did not get merit. The mission is still active even though we completed it successfully.

bump. 2 days after and still no merits. whats going on?

Edit: Upon checking it registered as a failed Guild challenge. WTF? We got our commendations and everything and it still registered as failed?

Yeh something happened with my guild as well. Bounty and trek went fine and awarded merits and commendations. Rush, challenge and puzzle still awarded commendations for participants but no merits were given to the guild for those 3 missions and it just counted down until the 5 hours were expired. This needs a fix asap.

Bumping.

This happened to our guild, DMoS on Blackgate, today. We got the quaggan rescue (Deep Trouble), successfully completed the challenge, the dynamic event popped up as succeeded, everyone involved got their weekly chest with commendations and other rewards, but the completion did not register and eventually the challenge ran out of time and got marked as failed. Guild did NOT get merits.

We had a slightly unusual sequence of events that we thought might have messed things up though…:

We started the challenge around 7:50am server time today but did not make a concerted attempt to do it until 5 hours later.

In the meantime, we started a bounty at noon which successfully completed 15 minutes later. Then, we started the challenge around 12:30 server time. We beat it 10 minutes later. The challenge then got marked as failed at 1:50pm server time, 6 hours after activation, even though we beat it less than 5 hours after activation.

A few of our thoughts on what might have caused the issue: 1) letting the challenge sit for too long before starting, 2) doing another mission (in our case, bounty) after starting the challenge but before successfully completing the challenge, or 3) someone in our guild may have ignored our messages and started the challenge without the rest of the guild and then failed it—could previous failures cause some sort of bug that prevents the guild from getting credit later?