Showing Posts For Kampfpinguin.4892:

Option to see player effectiveness

in Guild Wars 2: Heart of Thorns

Posted by: Kampfpinguin.4892

Kampfpinguin.4892

the funny thing is: such a system is already in place but i think it is not really working that well because it only tryes to count participation and its tied to loot wich i think in this case right now is resaonable but not reliable enough(sometimes no loot at the end if you use a wp because no one rezzed you and they killed some boss too fast). yes i m talking about gold silver bronze medals. wich right now are not really helpfull in terms of usefulness.

(edited by Kampfpinguin.4892)

Option to see player effectiveness

in Guild Wars 2: Heart of Thorns

Posted by: Kampfpinguin.4892

Kampfpinguin.4892

thats why i knew you didn t watch it. – thats not the point of the clip.

but your way of thinking is EXACTLY why i want such a notification.

you didn t even try to get some information you just tryed to use what i m calling broscience.

(edited by Kampfpinguin.4892)

Option to see player effectiveness

in Guild Wars 2: Heart of Thorns

Posted by: Kampfpinguin.4892

Kampfpinguin.4892

Mayga.7241 have you seen the video?`i dont think so.

Option to see player effectiveness

in Guild Wars 2: Heart of Thorns

Posted by: Kampfpinguin.4892

Kampfpinguin.4892

BrotherBelial.3094

i m not talking about pure dps!

for example if your traits are for boonremoval + healing then they could consider the dammage your party got from boons + your average healing done compared to others.

Option to see player effectiveness

in Guild Wars 2: Heart of Thorns

Posted by: Kampfpinguin.4892

Kampfpinguin.4892

mazut.4296 ??? right now people often get kicked because they aren t using “meta” – there is even sometimes gearcheck! i want a tool wich shows the result AFTER the instance to slowly prove those people wrong. -how can you kick someone after a game?

Option to see player effectiveness

in Guild Wars 2: Heart of Thorns

Posted by: Kampfpinguin.4892

Kampfpinguin.4892

DoctorDing.5890 it would help everyone with improving their playstile +build

Option to see player effectiveness

in Guild Wars 2: Heart of Thorns

Posted by: Kampfpinguin.4892

Kampfpinguin.4892

Liquicity.3621 exactly! and thats not what i m asking for thats why i wrote my example in my 1. post a notification at the end nothing more.

Option to see player effectiveness

in Guild Wars 2: Heart of Thorns

Posted by: Kampfpinguin.4892

Kampfpinguin.4892

@Mayga.7241 thats why i m talking about effectiveness not dps! and i m not saying i want to know what they are counting in their calculation+i dont want to see real time rankings you are right thats what those programms in wow are made for. But im convinced some kind of notification at the end of a fight would give everyone a very effective tool to improve if he wants to.

Option to see player effectiveness

in Guild Wars 2: Heart of Thorns

Posted by: Kampfpinguin.4892

Kampfpinguin.4892

@Rasimir.6239 you are right it is not easy and i am aware that

“Performance meters are a good tool in responsible hands, but in the hands of average mmo players they have a tendency to make people concentrate on only a very narrow part of the picture and often lead to rivalry among individual group members instead of concentration of what’s best for the group as a whole.”

but right now – as shown in my link above…right now manny groups are all about “broscience” -with such a tool we would at least have some way to prove them wrong.

(edited by Kampfpinguin.4892)

Stop crying about other people crying

in Guild Wars 2: Heart of Thorns

Posted by: Kampfpinguin.4892

Kampfpinguin.4892

just awesome.

Option to see player effectiveness

in Guild Wars 2: Heart of Thorns

Posted by: Kampfpinguin.4892

Kampfpinguin.4892

hi i always wondered why there is no “easy” way to see at least some kind of ranking at the end of especially boss fights in instances wich helps us get better.

i m not saying this because i want to get players with lower dps excluded – i personally try not to create or join Berserker meta groups. But to give everyone a chance to see his/her partipication on a particular fight and get a chance to actually see if he did well because he did the same ammount of work-not dammage! as the others or if he succeeded because 4 player were just carrying him through everything. my suggestion would be a bar wich counts everything dps ; healing ; boonremoval;… in one point for each player and in the end the party will be shown someting like a notification over the bonus chest:

player a: 20% player b: 15% player c: 25% player d: 25% player e: 15%

[==|=|=|=|===]

i m writing this because i like a nice community and right at the point where the end game players meet it gets salty. such bar would give everyone a better way to improve himself.
reallity until now shows:

No one really knows certain how effective his/her build really is and needs to rely on educated guessing + testing or getting infos from the community. exactly this is the reason why out of a good idea – not showing it to prevent people to exclude weaker chars – it actually caused that good groups exclude other good players because they rely on something others told them without even considering that ther are other good builds not only “meta zerg” ones.

i think such a bar would really help to see more builds actually played since then everyone could see what he´s doing and one way or another will really get a surprise.

a prominent example and main reason why i m writing this:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d2b7dpC0liQ

i think with such a bar this whole argument wouldnt have occured.