Ok so you want to forbid people to talk in their own language after that you prolly come up bashing them for not beeing able to use it perfectely. It would be better if they weren’t foreigners at all, right?
Whether they can use it perfectly is irrelevant aslong as they can get their point across in a language everyone can understand. I got no issues deciphering poorly written English, atleast they’re making an effort.
Public widespread chats are ment for everyone, not a select few that might speak another language than what is the standard on the very server you’re playing on.I’m playing on EU server. EU got 23 official languages :p
To be honest I think it’s pretty sad that we even have to discuss this matter. To use several languages seems so natural for me.I think there is a huge difference between people excluding others from the conversation and using another language. Of course if people are using the map-chat to make it their virtual living room it can get annoying if it’s going on for a long time. But thats not a matter of the language. You can perfectly well exclude others from a convo you are having simply by using references others don’t know and make it clear that others aren’t welcome to jump in.
Thats not really polite it’s the “people on the bus phenomenon” yelling at each other and making others listening without including them. Sure this is not cool for anyone. But I would never mind a convo I don’t understand which is going on for a few minutes until they use whisper or whatever. So it’s rather a matter of the dose and not of the fact itself.
It might be different if there is a server population that is speaking a certain language and dominating the chat while excluding the rest who is not able to speak this.
But to be honest on my server people barely speak at all. And bashing someone for not using the “right” language will only make people shutting themself out from a community that’s not welcoming them.And to shout someone down for using a language that you can not understand in the name of politeness is not really polite either.
Edit: I’m refering to the example the TO gave and don’t say you actually do.^^
Well, EU might have 23 official languages. Imo, the server does not. Just as you speak German on German servers and French on French ones you should speak English on a EU server in a widespread general chat, truth be told it’s the norm one should follow. There are ofcourse exceptions to this rule, sadly. Numerous games you’ll find servers beeing taken over by non English speaking players (and boy, I’ll tell you, they’re far cruder than we are. Yes I am refering to you Mr. Polak.) while shutting the English speaking ones out. And then the roles are reversed.
I’m not too concerned with beeing excluded from the conversation. Hell they can talk Pokemon all day in map chat for all I care, aslong as it’s in English. Whatever they may be talking about wouldn’t interest me the slightest whatever language they’re speaking in, I just find it bloody irritating and distracting having gibberish cluttering my chat.
The Virtual living room scenario you mention is exactly what I am going on about. While yes, the Guild recruitment posts are equally irritating it’s a minor distraction in comparison.
I don’t shout em off as you say either (I know you aren’t refering to me with that comment). Just silently sit by while others do it instead, contributing to the shout fest would be spam, which is just as annoying.
If as you say people shut themselves out from a English community because they don’t speak English themselves, I don’t see the problem, if they can’t speak it then they can’t be part of that community. Also there are several guilds out there for these people, a simple google search, which most should be able to do without much trouble would allow you to speak whatever language you’re comfortable with.