Guild Wars 2

TaCktiX.6729:

Problem 1: It’s Completely Expansion Exclusive
Negative Incentive: Why Not to Make Masteries Expansion Exclusive

TL;DR, The masteries associated with the core game should not be locked behind the expansion, but given to any owner of Guild Wars 2. This functions as both an incentive to get the expansion for the cooler Heart of Thorns part, and a way to keep the community together even when it “splits” over the expansion.

Problem 2: Mastery Track Tiers aren’t Horizontal
Levels by Any Other Name: Mastery Track Tiers

TL;DR, Masteries are vertical progression, just like the existing leveling system is. Calling it “not the typical” is disingenuous and builds hype that is bound to get disappointed. But with a few simple changes, it can shift from raw vertical to almost horizontal, with added benefits.

Ya, it will require the expansion. They are making something with the intent of you buying it. If you don’t buy it, you don’t get it. It is a sound business model, and a vocal minority aren’t okay with it. The majority of gamers are fine with paying for content, especially an MMO expanion’s worth.

As for vertical progression…you can freaking define anything as vertical progression that isn’t cosmetic. Get over it. There will always be vertical progression in a game that is DESIGNED TO KEEP YOU PLAYING. You won’t ever see otherwise, because people won’t play that game.

These are two very vocal complaints that are completely foolish.

There is no confirmation that rifle is the new weapon, so to those stating that as fact, please stop.

On topic, I think these are great ideas, although they might be a bit OP and need to be toned down lol.