Regarding the GS player you mentioned, his playstyle sounds a lot like mine, minus some of his abilities and behavior/attitude. Let me say a few words-
I could understand that GS and some of those abilities aren’t optimal. I used to raid on WoW pretty solid and strived to maintain the optimal build/stat builds and shot rotations(I played a hunter in Burning Crusade). That was fun, to an extent, because I played pretty seriously and I wanted to be the best. However, my attitude has changed as I’ve grown a little older and gained a difference perspective about gaming in general, and how I viewed them.
What was once something I put a lot of time into being the best at, I now use as a source of entertainment. I have no ambitions of being the best Guardian ever, rather, I want to enjoy myself. I stick with a GS because I spend more time by myself questing than in a dungeon, so I gather groups up and AoE them down which I find to be fun. I take support type abilities in dungeons to attempt to be helpful, since I am in a group. I’m working with MY character to contribute to the group. I feel as though if I play a game to enjoy myself, and desire to do dungeons because I enjoy those too, but force myself to do something I don’t find enjoyable, then I defeat my purpose of playing.
I understand that these thoughts may not apply to who you’re talking about, but I wanted to at least defend why some people don’t use an optimal build. I am with you 100% though using the most optimal strategies.
However, my argument actually in a way supports what you’re saying, in that dungeons should probably have two separate difficulties. One for a guy like me, and one for a a guy like you. Not to say, though, that the optimal build for your character specifically isn’t something you personally enjoy. It’s my understanding that guardians are more of a support/tank type class or whatever, whereas I enjoy their potential as a damage dealer. I do plan, however, to maximize my personal playstyle to give the most I can in a dungeon.
I didn’t mean for this to be argumentative, just maybe insightful to the thought process of your fellow gamer.
Not affiliated with ArenaNet or NCSOFT. No support is provided.
All assets, page layout, visual style belong to ArenaNet and are used solely to replicate the original design and preserve the original look and feel.
Contact /u/e-scrape-artist on reddit if you encounter a bug.