I didn’t want to quote your whole post as its quite large, but I did want to reference it as I feel you make some very good points. I agree on the captain America one and I too am desperate to get up into that drill thing to challenge scarlet at the controls.
I think the main problem is one of time difference, between the game and our experience of events. This part of the story is, from what I understand, actually the initial, sudden attack and a few hours afterwards, where citizens are evacuated in haste with anything they can carry. It makes sense for even the great heroes to get directly involved at this point, because they are still scouting and getting in whatever means (likely those teleporter things dotted about) that will help them get inside.
Unfortunately, with “game time”, those hasty, desperate few hours become two whole weeks in which we all do a groundhog day over and over. For two weeks, Roxx, Marjory and so on will still be saying “wow, its an attack on the city, omg giant drill”, when the rest of us will be thinking “can we stop evacuating people and get on with it”.
The karka event happened in a much more realistic timeframe, with an initial attack and then us going out to kick some crab behind. The problem with that, though, was that a lot of people missed the event. We were either there on the day of the attack or we missed it forever and it was the same for the defeat of the karka queen. I distinctly remember staying up into the early hours to see the mad king burst out of the fountain as well and after that…..he didn’t burst out again.
I can understand why it is that we get these “2 hours becomes 2 week” time situations. It allows all players to take part in the event and it justifies what is a heck of a lot of development effort that would be wasted if it lasted a mere eyeblink. It does, however, stretch the story to breaking point unless one takes into account these limitations.
On the topic of the “final battle”, we do know that certain parts of scarlets armour are dropping as future items. We know we will be fighting her. I suspect, however, that we will not be fighting whatever comes out of the drill hole. Scarlet’s use to that is at an end and we will surely defeat her soon, only to ponder the future arc of dealing with whatever it is she manages to dig up. I`m unsure quite how epic a fight she will be though.
Half of me thinks that we will get to the controls of the drill only to find her a burned out, mindless shell, disgarded by whatever it is that is urging her on.