Guild Wars 2

In the fights against Logan, I have noticed Scarlet saying “Thackeray loves a silly, fat-headed royal more than he loves you. Does that hurt?” I have only seen this on human female player characters (I have not tried a male human).

So, does Scarlet say the same thing for male human characters? If not, she seems to be insinuating or assuming that human female characters must have some sort of longing for Logan.

She says the same thing to all human characters, possibly to all characters who fight him (but I think the instance ‘owner’ has to be a human for him to appear).

It’s weird, I’m not sure where she’s getting that from because I’ve never gotten that impression from how Logan and your character act towards each other. At best their friendly.

I think you guys are taking “love” to mean romantically, where this is more platonic friendly love.

Keep in mind that ‘love’ does not always have to be romantic in nature, and the sylvari as a race are extremely young. This could simply be implying that Logan, though he considers you a friend, wouldn’t be there when you need him if Jenna where in trouble. Similarly to how Logan made the choice to abandon Destiny’s Edge to return to Kryta to save Jenna.

Dondagora.9645:

I think you guys are taking “love” to mean romantically, where this is more platonic friendly love.

The relationship between Logan and Jennah (or at least Logan’s feeling for Jennah( are romantic, so it doesn’t make sense for Scarlet to use the same word with 2 different meanings in 1 sentence.

Weird, that’s all.

I took it more as a love in terms of friendship. And I found it more along the lines of what LanfearShadowflame just mentioned, sure Logan might think my character is a good friend, but if the queen were in trouble, her problems would take priority over me.

I find it more as Scarlet is trying to drive a wedge/fuel doubt between you and your relationship with DE. Sylvari for example, when a Caithe hallucination appears, Scarlet says, “I’ll do you a favor. You can’t trust Caithe. She’s not the perfect bloom she pretends to be.” I assume Scarlet says things that might make you think twice with most of Destiny’s Edge, but I don’t have any other high level races.

TheKillerAngel.3596:

Dondagora.9645:

I think you guys are taking “love” to mean romantically, where this is more platonic friendly love.

The relationship between Logan and Jennah (or at least Logan’s feeling for Jennah( are romantic, so it doesn’t make sense for Scarlet to use the same word with 2 different meanings in 1 sentence.

Weird, that’s all.

Even weirder that it gets used as a taunt at all. I was under the impression that pretty much every knows Logan and Jennah are lovey dovey already and for anyone who has done the personal story they already knew that if Logan had to choose between Jennah or someone else it would always be Jennah. Both the player and the PC also knows Logan is unreliable, can’t hold his own in a fight and runs off when you need him.

LanfearShadowflame.3189:

Keep in mind that ‘love’ does not always have to be romantic in nature, and the sylvari as a race are extremely young. This could simply be implying that Logan, though he considers you a friend, wouldn’t be there when you need him if Jenna where in trouble. Similarly to how Logan made the choice to abandon Destiny’s Edge to return to Kryta to save Jenna.

just a slight correction I believe he returned to ebonhawk to save Jenna, (ebonhawk is in the far southern area of ascalon)

My giant black ebony norn got the same whisper so umm..yeah akward :p

TheKillerAngel.3596:

Dondagora.9645:

I think you guys are taking “love” to mean romantically, where this is more platonic friendly love.

The relationship between Logan and Jennah (or at least Logan’s feeling for Jennah( are romantic, so it doesn’t make sense for Scarlet to use the same word with 2 different meanings in 1 sentence.

Weird, that’s all.

Has anything with scarlet ever made sense?

I think the point about destiny’s edge is what she’s trying to get at here

also if it has to be romantic with regards to a female human there are actually random NPCs in open world that have dialogue that says they’re infatuated with him LOL I just saw a tumblr post with a screenshot of it. I believe he’s supposed to be this handsome good looking guy that everyone loves.

You saw that and somehow jumped to “she must think I long for Logan” when all of her lines in these instances are references to character conflicts? If you read Edge of Destiny (or played the story mode dungeons) you would see this is a dig at Logan’s decision to abandon Destiny’s Edge during the fight with Kralkatorrik to rescue Queen Jennah when she called for help. Their decision left Destiny’s Edge down a member resulting in the deaths of Snaff and Glint, the disbanding of the guild and it was the central conflict of the Story Mode dungeons (Rytlock in particular blames Logan for choosing the Queen over his guild). Scarlet is poking at old wounds (this particular one is weird because it’s personal for the members of Desinty’s Edge, not for the player) and that’s all.

I think it’s just badly worded. It probably should’ve been:

“Logan cares more about that silly fat-headed queen then he cares about you. Doesn’t that bother you a bit?”

I think she meant to say: “Hay gurl, Logan gone so cray cray over that uptown hussy that he forgot that you got swag.”

So yeah… played a female human necro in the tower…didn’t catch that at all. Lmao…XD

I was just too happy for the chance to pound Logan’s face in the dirt to even notice what the green cheerleader was chirping.

Too bad that it was just a hallucination, but one must take what’s given. >:-)

Nilkemia.8507:

I think it’s just badly worded. It probably should’ve been:

“Logan cares more about that silly fat-headed queen then he cares about you. Doesn’t that bother you a bit?”

And that is the problem, because the answer is (obviously) – “no, not at all”. It’s not like a human player would ever have a reason to expect Logan acting any other way, after all. It might be different for Destiny’s Edge, but no Destiny’s Edge member is even present in the instance.

Well, I think Scarlet was actually trying to convince you to join her side.

“Come join me, and I will give you pleasures yo can’t even imagine…

like the chance to blow Logan’s head off every time you want."

XD