I think as far as skins go we need more:
Black Lion skins with effects: Time Keeper and Bloodstone were good as they had moving effects and are very nice but some of the others that were released recently have been very meh. When there is a weapon set I like I buy them… ALL of them.
Here are the good ones that I liked and why:
Bloodstone: Cool Effect and nice color combo, Black and Red is always a classic and the weapons had nice lines
Spectral: Nice use of the “ghost” motif and cool side effects. Coolest blue themed weapons released
Timekeeper: these were my favorite in a LONG while. Excellent movement, nice lines and particle effects… just cool
Balthazar: Kind of kitten weapons… nice molten core texture thing going on. This is probably my favorite pistol design
Dominator: Not the best… but nice color combo (unusual) and very nice lines
Here are some of my least favorites and why:
Improvised: All of them are ugly
Gallant/Cavalier/Embellished: I get that these are for players that want more realistic looking weapons with cleaner designs but we are playing a game with giant horned cats and flower people… come on. I grouped these together because I dislike them all for the same reason. Again… I get some people like them but do we REALLY need 3 sets for those people?
Tempest: The effect was cool but I don’t think the devs did enough with the wind element.
Dwayna’s: Gross color combo. Little variety in shape and look between weapons.
Dreamthistle: The effect is kinda cool I guess I just don’t think it is as cool as some of the others
Glittering: Are these supposed to be weapons for female characters? Their presence is insulting. Seriously though I could see how someone might like them but I have never seen a character with a theme to match them nor does the available armor really support one.
Soaring: These look like they were very rushed. They glow kinda… thats it.
Merciless: These were actually really cool looking weapons but just are kinda meh when i see them on a character
Plasma: Cool design… but yellow? Really?
Privateer: Whoever decided to make Account Bound Black Lion skins messed these up. The only chance they had was on the trading post. These weren’t that good looking and now… if you got them… guess what… you’re stuck with them. They are very plain… and account bound.
Here are ones I think you should bring back:
Fused Weapons: I know they were rewards but that are so amazing! Good animation, nice lines, cool colors
Mordrem Weapons: Wasn’t a huge fan when they came out but they are growing on me. One of the only cool unique orange/blue weapons with a decent animation
Phoenix Weapons: A kitteneesey but still nice from time to time.
Immortal Weapons, Torment Weapons and Chaos Weapons: I think these are everyone’s all time favorites. I also think they should be brought back every year on the anniversary of GW1 release for just 24 hours. I definitely think we should be able to buy the Immortal weapons out right.
UNRELATED to that I also think the gem store should go back to offering armor sets (not just the one peice costumes) so we can mix and match a bit more. The first thing I ever bought from the gem store was my Elementalists flame armor with the nice effect. I was hoping you guys would actually release good ones for each of the elements like in the original guild wars (fire, lightning, ice, earth).
I’d also like some more chaos effect armor. A Margonite outfit would also be cool to match with the torment weapons. I just really wish it could go back to being mix and match armor. I feel like then we get really cool combos and huge variety.
I feel like we DON’T need:
-Account Boosters
-Gathering Tools
-Minis
-Back Packs that don’t do anything or have any animations
-Mail Carriers
-Dye kits that are basically the same colors over and over (however dyes that let us put effects on our characters are MORE than welcome… iridescent die, or see-through dye, or a dye that mimics the blade effects of dawn, twilight, or eternity but on your armor for instance… if you came out with that I would MAKE you TAKE MY MONEY!!!)
-Seasonal Costumes. These have been released for years now… there are only so many seasons…. we get it… halloween is scary and winter is cold.