Not sure why it wouldn’t make much sense, but surely there’s many things better that could be added to the guilds hall.
It’s an underground lake with no real way to rationalize how they got there in the first place. Very few sharks can live in freshwater and even then, they’re typically in freshwater connected to oceans such as rivers or an adjacent lake.
you guys complaining there cant be sharks in a mystical underground cave are silly , you do realize this is a game and its not 1:1 game real world , if you want an answer how can shark be in the guild halls then the answer is MAGIC , and if you are still confused the answer is again magic, the sharks seem a minor cool thing i dont see you complaining about the buble glider now do it ?
I wouldn’t have thought it’d take very long to add some sharks – they already have several different shark models in the game, they already have the animations and everything programmed in, the water is already there. All they’d need to do is set the game to spawn them.
Danielle Aurorel, Dear Dragon We Got Your Cookies [Nom], Desolation (EU).
There’s only so many dev hours in a day. There’s only so much money in the budget, Everything we ask devs to do costs them in time and money. Everything they work on is time taken away from working on something else. (Even just adding sharks somewhere takes someone to do it). If people ask devs to add or remove something then they need more argument than it would be cool. Lots of things would be cool but the costs means that they can’t be put in.
So, what is your argument to convince the devs to spend the time and money to add sharks? (Besides cool). Remember, they’re busy making an expansion and the next part of the Living Story so it has to be good enough to pull a dev from his already full plate of work to what you’re asking for.
Be careful what you ask for
ANet may give it to you.
you guys complaining there cant be sharks in a mystical underground cave are silly , you do realize this is a game and its not 1:1 game real world , if you want an answer how can shark be in the guild halls then the answer is MAGIC , and if you are still confused the answer is again magic, the sharks seem a minor cool thing i dont see you complaining about the buble glider now do it ?
Just like how Rytlock learned how to be rev by “magic” or anything else that you want to use that argument towards. It’s a bit ridiculous to use a catch all argument to justify whatever you want.
The anti posts are a little harsh. There is no indication that it is not salt water, there is a black lion shipwreck so there is access to the outside world. Developer time is something for developers to decide.
Personally I would love to have more animals and water creatures in the guild halls.
Even cooler… Change the guy you donate mats to in the guild hall into a fountain and have a shark jump out and bite off your left arm when you interact with it.
It’s an underground lake with no real way to rationalize how they got there in the first place. Very few sharks can live in freshwater and even then, they’re typically in freshwater connected to oceans such as rivers or an adjacent lake.
There’s a Veteran shark in the pool at the bottom of the Behem Gauntlet cave. It’s been there for 4 years now, so clearly the water is not a problem. I assume it uses players who aren’t good with jumping puzzles as a food source.
Not sure why it wouldn’t make much sense, but surely there’s many things better that could be added to the guilds hall.
It’s an underground lake with no real way to rationalize how they got there in the first place. Very few sharks can live in freshwater and even then, they’re typically in freshwater connected to oceans such as rivers or an adjacent lake.
The water in gilded hollow is not unconnected. There’s many sharks that live in underground water in Tyria already anyway. Gendarran Fields JP, Behem Gauntlet, Vexas Lab and Swashbucklers cove, and many other seemingly unconnected smaller lakes.
There’s always a reason one can come up with in a fictional and magical world.
Like an upgrade where you can place real wildlife in the guild hall as living decorations.
“It isn’t working!” CL4P-TP
Ingame Name: Guardian Erik
There’s only so many dev hours in a day. There’s only so much money in the budget, Everything we ask devs to do costs them in time and money. Everything they work on is time taken away from working on something else. (Even just adding sharks somewhere takes someone to do it). If people ask devs to add or remove something then they need more argument than it would be cool. Lots of things would be cool but the costs means that they can’t be put in.
So, what is your argument to convince the devs to spend the time and money to add sharks? (Besides cool). Remember, they’re busy making an expansion and the next part of the Living Story so it has to be good enough to pull a dev from his already full plate of work to what you’re asking for.
you do realize this is only your opinion and not everyone agrees with you , the devs should do things becasue it would be "cool"from time to time , adding a few sharks maybe an champ kill event like a megalodong in guild halls wouldt be to hard and would be cool.
There’s only so many dev hours in a day. There’s only so much money in the budget, Everything we ask devs to do costs them in time and money. Everything they work on is time taken away from working on something else. (Even just adding sharks somewhere takes someone to do it). If people ask devs to add or remove something then they need more argument than it would be cool. Lots of things would be cool but the costs means that they can’t be put in.
So, what is your argument to convince the devs to spend the time and money to add sharks? (Besides cool). Remember, they’re busy making an expansion and the next part of the Living Story so it has to be good enough to pull a dev from his already full plate of work to what you’re asking for.
you do realize this is only your opinion and not everyone agrees with you , the devs should do things becasue it would be "cool"from time to time , adding a few sharks maybe an champ kill event like a megalodong in guild halls wouldt be to hard and would be cool.
Yah?
Well good luck then getting a dev to quit what they’re doing to add sharks, without any compelling argument as to why they should do so.
Be careful what you ask for
ANet may give it to you.
There’s only so many dev hours in a day. There’s only so much money in the budget, Everything we ask devs to do costs them in time and money. Everything they work on is time taken away from working on something else. (Even just adding sharks somewhere takes someone to do it). If people ask devs to add or remove something then they need more argument than it would be cool. Lots of things would be cool but the costs means that they can’t be put in.
So, what is your argument to convince the devs to spend the time and money to add sharks? (Besides cool). Remember, they’re busy making an expansion and the next part of the Living Story so it has to be good enough to pull a dev from his already full plate of work to what you’re asking for.
you do realize this is only your opinion and not everyone agrees with you , the devs should do things becasue it would be "cool"from time to time , adding a few sharks maybe an champ kill event like a megalodong in guild halls wouldt be to hard and would be cool.
Yah?
Well good luck then getting a dev to quit what they’re doing to add sharks, without any compelling argument as to why they should do so.
i would call you something but i dont want to get banned again on forums if you want to talk about this further do you want to join me on discord serv ?
There’s only so many dev hours in a day. There’s only so much money in the budget, Everything we ask devs to do costs them in time and money. Everything they work on is time taken away from working on something else. (Even just adding sharks somewhere takes someone to do it). If people ask devs to add or remove something then they need more argument than it would be cool. Lots of things would be cool but the costs means that they can’t be put in.
So, what is your argument to convince the devs to spend the time and money to add sharks? (Besides cool). Remember, they’re busy making an expansion and the next part of the Living Story so it has to be good enough to pull a dev from his already full plate of work to what you’re asking for.
you do realize this is only your opinion and not everyone agrees with you , the devs should do things becasue it would be "cool"from time to time , adding a few sharks maybe an champ kill event like a megalodong in guild halls wouldt be to hard and would be cool.
Yah?
Well good luck then getting a dev to quit what they’re doing to add sharks, without any compelling argument as to why they should do so.
i would call you something but i dont want to get banned again on forums if you want to talk about this further do you want to join me on discord serv ?
Naw.
If you are unable to continue a civil discussion because I told you that extremely busy people need a good reason to add more work to their pile, but instead want to go somewhere to say things that forum rules forbid, why should I want to listen to that?
But good luck in getting your sharks.
Be careful what you ask for
ANet may give it to you.
There’s only so many dev hours in a day. There’s only so much money in the budget, Everything we ask devs to do costs them in time and money. Everything they work on is time taken away from working on something else. (Even just adding sharks somewhere takes someone to do it). If people ask devs to add or remove something then they need more argument than it would be cool. Lots of things would be cool but the costs means that they can’t be put in.
So, what is your argument to convince the devs to spend the time and money to add sharks? (Besides cool). Remember, they’re busy making an expansion and the next part of the Living Story so it has to be good enough to pull a dev from his already full plate of work to what you’re asking for.
you do realize this is only your opinion and not everyone agrees with you , the devs should do things becasue it would be "cool"from time to time , adding a few sharks maybe an champ kill event like a megalodong in guild halls wouldt be to hard and would be cool.
Yah?
Well good luck then getting a dev to quit what they’re doing to add sharks, without any compelling argument as to why they should do so.
i would call you something but i dont want to get banned again on forums if you want to talk about this further do you want to join me on discord serv ?
Naw.
If you are unable to continue a civil discussion because I told you that extremely busy people need a good reason to add more work to their pile, but instead want to go somewhere to say things that forum rules forbid, why should I want to listen to that?
But good luck in getting your sharks.
It sounded like he was trying to “call you out” for a fight really. Which is both ridiculous and sad.
There’s only so many dev hours in a day. There’s only so much money in the budget, Everything we ask devs to do costs them in time and money. Everything they work on is time taken away from working on something else. (Even just adding sharks somewhere takes someone to do it). If people ask devs to add or remove something then they need more argument than it would be cool. Lots of things would be cool but the costs means that they can’t be put in.
So, what is your argument to convince the devs to spend the time and money to add sharks? (Besides cool). Remember, they’re busy making an expansion and the next part of the Living Story so it has to be good enough to pull a dev from his already full plate of work to what you’re asking for.
you do realize this is only your opinion and not everyone agrees with you , the devs should do things becasue it would be "cool"from time to time , adding a few sharks maybe an champ kill event like a megalodong in guild halls wouldt be to hard and would be cool.
Yah?
Well good luck then getting a dev to quit what they’re doing to add sharks, without any compelling argument as to why they should do so.
i would call you something but i dont want to get banned again on forums if you want to talk about this further do you want to join me on discord serv ?
Naw.
If you are unable to continue a civil discussion because I told you that extremely busy people need a good reason to add more work to their pile, but instead want to go somewhere to say things that forum rules forbid, why should I want to listen to that?
But good luck in getting your sharks.
It sounded like he was trying to “call you out” for a fight really. Which is both ridiculous and sad.
Or probably like the poster said take it to a different forum where the black knight would not report them for being off topic?
you do realize this is only your opinion and not everyone agrees with you , the devs should do things becasue it would be "cool"from time to time , adding a few sharks maybe an champ kill event like a megalodong in guild halls wouldt be to hard and would be cool.
Yah?
Well good luck then getting a dev to quit what they’re doing to add sharks, without any compelling argument as to why they should do so.
Obviously with subjective matters like this, some people might find it not fun not cool or whatever. But I’m pretty sure that many developers in a game wants to add things to the game they find cool.
Some people want things to be realistic and make perfect sense (which they believe to be cool), some people like ridiculous things like a bow that shoots unicorns. There is very little ELSE than the argument that “I find this or that cool” So I’m not sure what you’re trying to say with a compelling argument besides cool.
(Not that I disagree that the suggestion is a bit limited in entertainment value, I did suggest to widen it beyond just sharks, plus now OP said something like a shark-event which really is just another version of many other suggestions of adding events to guild halls. But there’s really no other reason necessary besides being cool)
Dev-time allocation discussions are a bit pointless btw. It could be basically said for every suggestion that it shouldn’t be added because it takes time to do so.
“It isn’t working!” CL4P-TP
Ingame Name: Guardian Erik
If you really want to make your Guild Hall waters dangerous, add piranhas. They’ll take out any shark with no problems.
Asura characters: Zerina | Myndee | Rissa | Jaxxi | Feyyt | Bekka | Sixx | Akee | Tylee | Nuumy
| Claara
Your skin will wrinkle and your youth will fade, but your soul is endless.
I’m going to suggest rapidly respawning packs of pocket raptors for the guild halls then, and make them able to swim also.
I think they would be cool.
Oh, Pocket Raptors with with piranhas strapped to their backs!
Asura characters: Zerina | Myndee | Rissa | Jaxxi | Feyyt | Bekka | Sixx | Akee | Tylee | Nuumy
| Claara
Your skin will wrinkle and your youth will fade, but your soul is endless.
