Guild Wars 2

When first they were first announced, it was stated that periodically, guilds would need to defend or re-claim their halls from attacks. No further information about this aspect of Guild Halls has since been forthcoming and I’m wondering (hoping) that the idea has been dropped.

If not, how is this going to work, Will all upgrades (or the hall itself) be lost if the guild doesn’t reclaim within a set amount of time? and how feasible is this for small guilds who may have members away?

Anyone else feel that given the time and effort that upgrading the halls is going to require, that this particular element is unwanted and unnecessary?

As nothing was touched on it during Guild Week, I think it is safe to assume it has been dropped.

Defending it should have to happen, but it should be scaled for the number of people currently present in the GH, IMO.

Zalladi.4652:

As nothing was touched on it during Guild Week, I think it is safe to assume it has been dropped.

That was what I was hoping, but as we have had no official word – some additional feedback from players (assuming, most think its a bad idea) might encourage them to re-think it, if indeed it is still to be implemented.