I’m comforted to see that this isn’t just me. I just rolled a new character and lost my titles (Didn’t have GWAMM but did have up to Flameseeker)
Strangely, all the skins I had unlocked are still accessible; I haven’t checked the HoM to see if Kimmes will still fork over the items though.
Edit: Once I got the new character out of the starting area, I used the HoM stone and talked to Kimmes; he offered me the items I had unlocked and all of my titles returned. All is well.
(edited by Destillat.9658)