Its an interesting idea. I just don’t think anyone has ever come up with a solid solution on implementation that moves us away from stacking. I’ve been in a few guilds over the years that enjoy being the underdog. But they are the exception.
I am not certain that new servers would function all that well without some sort of incentive to move. Resetting the Glicko rating would help. Our core group of WvW players often seems to operate in a manner different than how Anet expects us to function. Polls are tough considering anyone can take a poll! We need something new to rejuvenate the game mode. Right now I feel like the players are driving the bus which isn’t how it should be.