Problem – Your responding to a very different topic. The issue that this person is mentioning he’s running into isn’t that he can’t join the dungeons or even select which one he wants to attend, rather that he can’t get glue OR stuffing that is required to make many of the rewards from this holiday event. For instance he can’t make the Endless Tonics or the Golem Toy mini pet because he is no longer being reward the mats to make them. I to have this issue and I hope Anet allows us to reliably and repeatedly acquire more of the Enchanted Stuffing and Drops of Glue so we can actually enjoy the items they put effort into making.
What doesn’t work – Black Lion is not a reasonable solution as the prices for even ONE of these items is 1 silver. Assuming you had neither Glue or Stuffing you would have to spend 1 gold only to have a CHANCE at getting ONE tonic. That is not including the other mats that you need.
Effect – This makes it very hard for casual, new, or poorer players to enjoy a casual event as they probably don’t have their pockets lined with gold. (Unless they are relatively wealthy IRL and are willing to spend it).
Possible Solution -
1 – Returning the Stuffing and Glue drops to Tixx’s dungeon completion.
2 – Make the Wintersday Gifts drop Glue or Stuffing but maybe only 1 – 5.
3 – Make the holiday vendor sell Glue and Stuffing for the all too plentiful Ugly Wool Socks/Hat/Sweater.This IS a issue, people wouldn’t post it on the forums in mass if it wasn’t. People like to play this game, it makes sense to let them actually have fun with it not bar them from it. Have a good one guys, Happy Wintersday and Happy Holidays.
id like to give some feedback to your solutions
1. maybe but not realy. this would make wad/ glue worhless. making the endless tonics worth next to nothing and way to common.and if the reward was to low it would be to grindy.
2. there is already a small chance 25 wad/glue drop from boxes. all boxes have an equal chance of getting them. its a rare drop though. but in the end of the event the price should be alot more wellcomming to poorer peoplethats why i sold all of mine. and to buy it back later.
3.see 1.
I hope you understand why 1 or 3 cant be done. and the 2nd one already is in effect.Merry Christmas!
I meant to be relatively loose on my solutions and it’s my fault for not stating so in my original post, so apologies.
For your response on 1 yes I realize it would make the items worth less but if that’s the case then simply lower the amount that drops to 100, 50, or even 25.
2, Yes it’s already in effect but that shouldn’t count, as the drop rate for them is less than 0.1%: http://wiki.guildwars2.com/wiki/Giant_Wintersday_Gift/drop_rate. What I was trying to say is increase the drop rate to something more reasonable and maybe lower how many you get this way people have a much better shot at achieveing their goal without needing to spend gold.
I don’t see why 3 shouldn’t work so long as pricing for each item is made reasonably.
The holiday events aren’t meant to be a stock exchange bonanza, it is literally a time for merry making and spreading cheer. It’s hard for people to spread that cheer when they don’t have the resources to do so.