Guild Wars 2

Thx for reply, Eisenhart.
As you mentioned, I missed 2 big things. One is alliance, the other is every guilds are not enjoying WvW. Because of this, I’ll reconsider this ideas.

I have more specific ideas on item1 to 4. But even if solve this problems, because of above 2 missing things, this idea should be fixed.

New Idea: Guild Ranking + WvW

GW2 WvW is very attractive. But it has many problems. Similar routine of battle makes it bored. Timezone and population issues make unfair battles. Free server transfer makes server ranking meaningless. Your enemy don’t know how you and your guild’s are good. If you think these things right, read my new ideas.

1. Mix guilds every X weeks.

No longer free transfers are allowed. Instead of it, guilds and ppl are transferred automatically by system. In detail, servers are reset every X weeks. Every guilds and ppl are distributed to whole other servers. When transferring, system considers their timezone and popularities to all servers get balanced.

2. Sort by guilds instead of servers

GW2’s free transfer makes ppl have little affection on their servers. WvW Server ranking is no longer such important to those ppl. Apply Guild ranking system. HOW? as I mentioned at the 1, servers are reset every X weeks. End of the day, gives points to those guilds based on the server’s WvW point. Then ranks guild by this points.

This idea’s advantage is follows.

1. Easy implementation.
No changes on the WvW. server transfer? it’s already existed. Only work to do is guild distribution system and ranking system by analyzing database.

2. WvW is no longer bored.
Every X weeks, WvW got big changes. All neighbor guilds’ and ppl are changed. You can get together with other famous guilds.

3. No longer cry on outnumbered and timezone issue.
When mixing guilds, system will consider their timezone, populations and guild rankings to normalize servers.

4. Real Guild Wars.
Result of WvW war? It’s your guild’s point, guild’s ranking. Want to show your guild is good guild? Participate the WvW and earn the points. Guild ranking system will give a reward for your contribution.

WvW guild ranking system

Before saying my ideas, sorry for my bad English. I’m not a native speaker.
But my idea is very cool. So please read this thread.

I like WvW. But while enjoying WvW, I feels some insufficiency. So I suggest new WvW system.

Current WvW problems are like this.
First, in the WvW, ppl and guilds can not be famous. No user name tags, No ranking systems.
Although having server ranking system, ppl have lack of affection for their own server. Many ppl and guilds use server transfer system very frequently.

Second, as time goes, WvW gets boring… There r no changes in WvW.. Similar routines are repeated..

Third, WvW balancing issues.. timezone problems.. and misc.

My new idea can solve these all problems.. To explain easily, I’ll call my system as ‘W system’.

If W system is applied, server transfer is no longer possible. But every 2 weeks, all servers are reset.. and every guilds are distributed to random servers.. So those servers are made up with mixed guilds.. Distribution is not pure random. W system consider guilds timezone and populations and misc.. After distribution, WvW gets started again..

End of the 2 weeks, all guilds gets points by based on their server points. With these points, W system calculates guilds’ rankings..

This is rough ideas.. but W system can solve many WvW issues.. balancing problems, boring WvW problems(every 2 weeks WvW gets big changes) and Guild appealing desires..
W system implementation is a little easy. There are no changes on the WvW. Server transfer is already exist. Only work to do is balanced distribution system.. but this can be done by analyzing only DBs..

There can be some trivial issues.. no guild person.. not active users.. But I think these things are trivial things..

Kfree, WarMachine