Guild Wars 2

Clearly there is a divide in the belief on the state of the Elementalist: Is he under-powered or balanced? Everyone has their own opinion and feelings on the matter, and that is good. The problem, however, is that we lack data. We lack the concrete evidence of the success or failure of the Elementalist as a profession. So, I propose that we, as a community that obviously loves this profession, collect this data.

I propose that we engage in 1v1 bouts against the other professions.

Yes, I know that sPvP is a team game. (Believe me, I am an avid fan and player of League of Legends. I’ve given the “team game” speech before.) I also know that a good team needs to be composed of individuals that can handle themselves when alone.

The bouts should be recorded in some fashion [screencap, video, note and paper, etc]. For this to be even remotely helpful, we’d need as much data as possible: builds of both parties, how long the bout lasted, damage taken/given. If we can come together and compile this information, then we should be able to get a real idea of the strengths/weaknesses of the Elementalist. If it turns out that the Elementalist is UP, then the data could be offered to the ANet masters as tribute. If the Elementalist turns out to be balanced, then a nice serving of humble pie will be served out to everyone who thought otherwise—myself included.

Long story short, data doesn’t lie. With the appropriate amount of data, we can see through the fog of frustration that plagues the Elementalist community.

That’s my idea. Take it or leave it.

Kyros, I’m afraid that you are going to need to post more videos. Those videos need to feature different builds. Those builds need to be successful, as well. That’s the only true way you can build a case on the belief that the “Elementalist is strong.” Right now, your one build only features one play-style which cannot possibly defend every aspect of the Elementalist.

I had a friend who was in a similar predicament, having come from WoW playing a shaman.
I told him that, since the weapons are what define the skills, test the weapons of each profession. Yes, it will take a while, but it will be worth it to find what you vibe with most. Off the bat, I would suggest starting with a Guardian.