Showing Posts For Purina.5613:

20 tokens for 1 hour and 30 minutes of bullcrap

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

1. Your day is not the same as Anet’s day. (Example: I did a dungeon yesterday evening at 9pm and got 60 tokens. I did that same dungeon and path again today at 4:30pm and only got 20 tokens… KJBUH*&^% your system is broke right? Wrong – The dungeon dailies don’t reset till 7pm on my server so it is technically still the same day)

2. I ran cof path 1 fall asleep mode in 20 minutes and only get 20 tokens. KJBUH*&^% your system is broke right? Wrong – Diminishing returns kicked in for the speed run exploit farmers and shafted you. Slow down. This game rewards slow players, not effecient players.

Looking for a complete guide on all Dungeons

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

Look in the sticky section – that’s about as good as it gets right now.

Speed runs are out of control

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

Theres a real simple fix to all this trash mob and boss skipping garbage. The MMO that isn’t allowed to be mentioned found out how:

Choke points at bosses… you must go through a narrow section at each boss to get to the next section.

Anti-trash mob skip mechanic… any boss that is aggro’ed simply auto aggro’s all mobs preceeding him. Woohoo we skipped those 5 packs of risen and got to the boss in a record 60 seconds and start dps’ing his sorry rear end and all of a sudden everyone dies from the horde of angry risen that just came running aorund the corner from the previous hallway.

Throw those two fixes in there and you solve, most if not all of the speed run bull pukey.

AOE question

in Players Helping Players

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

Is anybody out there…

AOE question

in Players Helping Players

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

Was having a debate today about AOE with a buddy and I distinctly remeber reading somewhere that aoe can only hit 4 mobs at a time. Buddy thinks I am FOS and I could not back up my statement of only hitting 4 mobs at a time with AOE. I cant remember where I read it at.

Can anyone “for sure confirm” that AOE can hit more than 4 mobs or caps at 4 mobs. Example would be that there are 6 mobs standing in an Elementalist Skill Shower and lets say that it pulses damage once every second on 4 of the 6 mobs, however each pulse isnt guranteed to hit the same 4 mobs on each pulse. Pulse 1 hits mobs 1-4, pulse 2 hits mobs 2-5, pulse 3 hits mobs 3-6 and so forth.

My buddy is saying that as it pulses each second so long as all 6 mobs are in the target area it will hit all 6 mobs on every damage pulse.

If this 4 cap is true and you can confirm where it says it at, that would be fantastic. This question isn’t a complaint about skill shower at all and the mechanic of skill shower could be very different from what I listed (I don’t play an elementalists so I don’t know) I just chose to use it as my made up example since it’s a very common form of AOE seen in the game.

Will we get hard modes for dungeons?

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

Only having one hand/ arm would still be easy for anyone with a razr Naga… you can do everything with just a mouse.

Then follow Hard Mode options 1 or 3

Finding a Dungeon Group

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

Careful daisy thier dungeons just got nerfed… your likely to start a riot…

Will we get hard modes for dungeons?

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

I currently run all my dungeons in 146% MF gear. They are still doable even with that handicap.

Try my three listed handicaps, bet they turn those easy mode dungeons into a nightmare.

1) Use an eye patch to cover one eye
2) Tie one arm behind your back
3) No sitting down, only standing in front of you keyboard and mouse.

PS. Pics/Vids or it didnt happen.

Awesome ambient room in CoF ; not used at all?

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

The oddyssey refereance is a stretch wolfey… the single shaft of light from a hole in the cavern ceiling highlighting the coffin is far from it.

Awesome ambient room in CoF ; not used at all?

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

I love stuff like this, even if it’s just there for fun/flavor.

and light coming from the a small hole in the ceiling, directly to the coffin…. RIPOFF from Lord of the rings

Right, because Lord of the Rings didn’t get take any inspiration from past works or anything…

Got no idea about that, just recognised that scene from the scene in LOTR. Not a huge fan or anything.

Will we get hard modes for dungeons?

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

Heres another suggestion… No chair’s allowed, you can only run these dungeons standing up at your desk, no sitting down… See if thier easy now, yeh !

Will we get hard modes for dungeons?

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

Giving yourself handicaps is a horrible suggestion. Thats like suggesting to take of half your armor or wear lvl 70 greens instead of lvl 80 exotics.

They are the ones complaining of it being too easy… this suggestion would make it not easy (Guranteed) and keep the majority happy while also lessening the work load of the dev’s.

Everyone wins…

Awesome ambient room in CoF ; not used at all?

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

and light coming from the a small hole in the ceiling, directly to the coffin…. RIPOFF from Lord of the rings

Black Lion Trading Company CEO Complaint

in Black Lion Trading Co

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

NEWS FLASH ! ! ! !

Evon Gnashblade indicted today on Profiteering charges stemming from a SEC investigation. Evon’s reply to these charges:

“I aim to flank, encircle, and eliminate the competition!” & "I intend to dominate the marketing battlefield "

Guess he isn’t denying anything… Rumor has it that he is also about to be brought up on charges of treason for colluding with the highwaymen whom he has said in the past plague his routes and is the main reason why he only allows you to pick up your traded goods in town. When we at cnn confronted evon with his past statement of:

“I have trustworthy traders throughout Tyria”

Evon refused to comment on the above statement stating his lawyer had advised him not to.

Need some advice on gear/spec

in Ranger

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

what are you planning to spend the majority of your time doing(WvWvW, SPvP, PVE Dungeons, DE’s) and who with (Organised guild groups or pugs)?

Whats your play style? You like staying alive and supporting, You like pew pewing, You like trapping and kiting…

Need more information as there is not a single trait set that rules them all.

Black Lion Trading Company CEO Complaint

in Black Lion Trading Co

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

How cool would it be if there were a Dynamic Event at the BLTC Headquarter’s were the highwaymen had put up a seige and were trying to overrun the place.

If the seige succeded there would be no TP transactions for an hour or so for everyone. If the seige was defeated then those who participated got a bag of gems, or no TP fee’s for a day or just something relating to the TP. A seige once a week would be awesome.

Mess with a players ability to make money and I am betting people would come out of the wood works to take that seige down.

Will we get hard modes for dungeons?

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

I really spank my ten year old son in Halo… he complained about it so we came up with the idea of patching one of my eye’s, so I can only see out of one. I didn’t spank him so easily then and he won more than I did. Try it… trust me it adds a whole new element and makes it much more difficult.

Black Lion Trading Company CEO Complaint

in Black Lion Trading Co

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

Your right… I smell a SEC investigation on the horizon for the BLTC.

Will we get hard modes for dungeons?

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

I got an ide how you can make it harder in the meantime… Tie one arm behind your back, bet it wouldn’t be so easy then ?

LOL

Black Lion Trading Company CEO Complaint

in Black Lion Trading Co

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

I am just curious how I can file a formal complaint against the CEO of the Black Lion Trading company for deriliction of duty. I recently sold some items, on said trading post, while standing outside CoF and was told I had to travel to a major city to pick up the funds from my transaction. I was also told that the BLTC would not mail my funds to me because of a group of highway bandit’s specifically targeting and robbing the mail carrier’s who transported said transaction funds.

I would like to file a complaint or at the very least organise a possey to take down those highwaymen so I don’t have to find a major city to pick up my funds everytime I make a transaction. The highwaymen have got to go… my funds not being mailed to me is a major pain in the … well you know.

Fix your game Anet

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

edited by me cause this all seems fixed now.

(edited by Purina.5613)

Feedback: Dungeon Experience

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

good read… but Anet doesn’t care about the casuals and pugger’s and your just gonna get flamed by the fan boys and trolls.

Tips for a newcomer

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

cof is easily puggable. I pug it every day for my pretty fire armor. Don tell puggers your new or they will spaz. Just follow the other 4 and do what they do.

Must pugs do path 2 as it’s the fastest and easiest. and the only thing i can think of for a brand new dungeoneer causing problems for the whole group in path 2 is the last boss. On that one just dont kill your assigned add until told to do so. Theres always an alpha pugger who likes to assign adds and dictate that fight.

Sarrow's Embrace Explorable... Help needed

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

For those that have offered help & info namely Zenyatoo, Lorana, AzureDream. Much appreciated.

Sarrow's Embrace Explorable... Help needed

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

just do it for the first time,like everyone else,and if you encounter any problems google the boss name,you will usually find info on how to defeat it.

Thats not very helpful. I am not looking for someone to direct me to do it on my own with no assistance. Reread my first post again if you need to…

Have you ever heard the saying “Prior Planning prevents pis-poor performance”?

Sarrow's Embrace Explorable... Help needed

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

any tips, strats or advice on the other paths? anyone?

Should I have posted this in the “Players helping Players” index cause this index seems to be mostly complaint threads, not that there’s anything wrong with that? Where’s a mod to move a thead when you need one…

Sarrow's Embrace Explorable... Help needed

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

We plan to hit Sarrow’s Embrace later tonight as a guild for the first time and can’t find any information on the path’s or the boss strat’s. Can any of you PRO dungeoneer’s offer some boss tips, trash tips, what to watch out for, or path suggestions that might keep us from a night of slaughter?

Any tips, links, or help is greatly appreciated.

PS. Group make up will be a Ranger, 2 Warrior’s, Necro, Guardian. We have cleared the other explorable’s prior to this and always find that the first time in any explorable so far can be very costly and were just hoping to save some cash and time.

Citadel of Flame broken

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

dfid it fine about 12 hours ago

CoF Explorer Path 2 - Bug's?

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

Did Twilight Arbor forward-forward the night before last with some guildies and one of my guildies was level 78 and it was his very first dungeon run ever. He has never stepped foot in any dungeon and upon completion of this run he got 15 tokens.

Everyone else got 60 tokens including myself. Why did he only get 15 on his first dungeon of the game?

Additionally, there seems to be an exploit with the lava river event in cof path 2. Did it with some puggers last night and immediatly after the event where you pretend its an east egg hunt with the bombs bringing them to the npc, everyone waypoints back to the start and the part were the npc has to cross the lava river does so on it’s own without anyone there. The puggers said this is how people are doing it now. Thats pretty lame and needs fixed.

Twilight Arbor Blossoms - NERD RAGE

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

Decrease the spawn rate or at the very least make it were after you kill one and it re-spawns it doesn’t fracking blow up before it appears on your screen, these things are horrible. Time after time POOF a big green cloud appears and there was no blossom there.

One party members only job was killing those things the whole instance… that’s all he did when they were around and they are as thick as roaches in a section 8 apartment. That’s not cool to lose a party member to mindless spamming in circles around us to clear a dungeon.

On a side note the actual bosses were laughably easy.

CoF Explorer Path 2 - Bug's?

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

Alright so I got the 20 tokens at around 11 am that I was whining about earlier, did cof path 2 again around 8ish pm (same calendar day) and got 60 so that confirms the time zone gobbeldy guk that was mentioned above. Did TA forward-forward around 1am and got another 60 tokens as well.

Definitely the time zone was what hosed me.

Same lava bather in every stinking COF path 2, bug’s out every time resulting in the group porting to the way-point and running back to get him to act right. PLEASE FIX THIS?

Still cant kill any of the char’s in the Magg bomb room and can only get past the event by kiting them out of the room and playing yo yo with their leashes. Please don’t put a door there or the dungeon will be undo-able, just reduce their health.

CoF Explorer Path 2 - Bug's?

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

Why all the caps about the time thing… did you miss this post:

“I’m just having fun with ya on the above post… need to wait 24 hours.. got it.”

Here is a MOOD lightning accurate representation of the char bomb room…
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_rsAbj3Xly0
Seriously watch it, it’s funny as H E double hockey sticks and did you see how I used all the caps there?

Time zone calculations and it starts sounding like charlie brown’s mom talking… got it wait 24 hours…

CoF Explorer Path 2 - Bug's?

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

I’m just having fun with ya on the above post… need to wait 24 hours.. got it. however that’s lame. will just have to get in and get the other paths done later this eve.

CoF Explorer Path 2 - Bug's?

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

Purina, you got 20 tokens on that run because it was your second run of the day, not your first. The day doesn’t reset until 12 AM GMT, not your personal timezone.

No it was a different day… I went to bed… had some fun with the misses.. slept all night… got up and ate breakfast… got online and ran it again… my calendar even showes it was a different day?

CoF Explorer Path 2 - Bug's?

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

what happened to the 1 hour DR?

Additionally if I go back in there in a couple hours when the rest of my group gets ready and we complete path 1 are we going to get 60 or 20?

(edited by Purina.5613)

CoF Explorer Path 2 - Bug's?

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

HaHa right below that in the same thread is another post by a Jon of Anet:

https://forum-en.gw2archive.eu/forum/game/dungeons/Dungeon-Patch-9-25-UPDATE-9-26/first#post262636

“I just wanted to update everyone on where we stand with this. So far we have found a single bug with the system that is causing certain players to get stuck in a state of reduced rewards without actually exploiting. A fix for this has already been made and is being tested locally now. We are going to do more significant testing on this new version but we also believe it is more bulletproof to begin with. Please keep posting data as these cases are somewhat rare and are hard for us to find with internal testing but seem to be exposed quickly when thousands of people are playing the dungeons.

All rewards are susceptible to our code that is dealing with people who are speed clearing dungeons. This means that if you are speed clearing and then play some new chain for the first time it may not reward the full 60 tokens. If you find yourself getting less rewards consider whether or not your rate of dungeon completion is extremely high."

So if I am getting DR on the second run because we cleared it too fast then that would mean our dps is too high… were clearing it too fast and speed running it on our second run ever on explorer mode, however we still cant dps fast enough to keep the char’s in the Bomb room knocked down so …

either the DR system is crap and I’m getting ripped off on tokens or the char’s need thier health knocked down, right? Which is it?

(edited by Purina.5613)

CoF Explorer Path 2 - Bug's?

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

What about the lava bather and the char serial killer’s, Bugs / Intended ? I got patience…. sometimes

CoF Explorer Path 2 - Bug's?

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

Robert Hrouda GAME DESIGNER Anet employee posted the following in another thread here:
https://forum-en.gw2archive.eu/forum/game/dungeons/Dungeon-Patch-9-25-UPDATE-9-26/first#post262636

“If you are experiencing Diminished Returns, it is due to clearing dungeons too quickly. If you feel you are unfairly being punished by our DR system, please post about it and we will review it when possible to see if the system is working as intended. The more info you give us the better.”

Previous run was 12 hours prior to this run. Why did i not get 60 tokens again and only 20? Additionally it took us about an hour to clear it the first time and then 12 hours later it took us about forty-five minutes. Same path Same dungeon, no other dungeons were ran between then and now. We did no exploits as far as i know unless pulling the chars out of the bomb room is an exploit but if it is, why did i get 60 the previous time and we did that room the exact same as this time? Is that what caused this or is it a DR bug of some sort?

An answer would be nice. Ive been pretty patient today…

CoF Explorer Path 2 - Bug's?

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

Hmm did this the first time last night around 22:00 CST and got 60 token like all my other group members. Did it just now at 11:50 am and got only 20 tokens?

Why is that? It’s like 12 hours between runs… thought the DR was supposed to be 1 hour?

EDIT: This run today took about 45 minutes to complete also. This time the dumb npc who likes to take baths in the lava just disappeared instead of taking a lava bath and we all ported back to the first way-point and ran back and he followed us across no problems.

(edited by Purina.5613)

CoF Explorer Path 2 - Bug's?

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

Anet? you there? “Bug” or “As Intended”?

This really makes me upset.

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

Just make sure you are always the first in and the problem is solved

This really makes me upset.

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

was he the one who entered the dungeon first? If so, that’s what caused your group to get kicked or so has been my experience.

No tokens in story mode?

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

mind.blown.
I have finished all the the dungeons and done every dungeon in exp mode and only challenging dungeon was Crucible of Eternity(exp mode).Sorry to say sir,but your bad.

This dude is asking about not getting tokens on story mode and mentions it was thier guilds FIRST run. Did you read his post or just start in with your troll spam right away? People like you make the forums suck.

LFG for all Dungeon explorer's [Eradon Terrace]

in Guilds

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

Up to 2 members in my Static pug. Going forward a couple things need to be made clear before agreeing to join up. I am not setting these terms because I am an a-hole but because some of these things have caused problems over the last couple days.

1) This is a static pug that wants to run as frequently as possible (every day if possible) in the early evenings (usually from 6pm-9pm cst) This is not a one time run LFG and then never see you again.

2) If you don’t have a mic and willing to use ventrilo and communicate then we don’t need you. Voice chat for these explorer’s is a must. I’m a horrible typer and so are most players, not to mention typing in a boss fight equals death.

3) If you don’t speak English and like to fill the chat box with Asian gobbeldy kitten then you cant be a member. Understanding us and being able to communicate with you is a must.

4) Bad attitude’s and we really don’t need you. I’m so awesome cause I farmed arah and cof exploits to get a full set of exotics in 1 week type people need not apply

This group is for puggers who want to clear the content and not cheat doing it on a daily basis because they want that shiny cool armor that costs a ton of tokens. Preferably puggers just starting out as they seem to have the best attitudes. I can work with someone who is agreeable but the jaded whiner’s and complainer’s i’ve got no patience with.

All I need is 3 more people who can follow the above and want to get some phat loots and work together as a team?

CoF Explorer Path 2 - Bug's?

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

First off – the group does not have full exotics. We just recently started doing explorer modes. In fact this was our second one ever.

Did CoF Explorer Path 2 for the first time last night against the warning of multiple people standing around outside the dungeon swearing up and down it was now un-doable. We finished it in about an hour or so but did have two problems throughout the dungeon that we feel Anet might need to take a look at.

Forgive me for not knowing names of npc and mobs and such as this was our groups first time running CoF on explorer mode, however I will do my best to explain in detail.

Issue 1
The part were you have to escort the npc across the river of lava and use the fire extinguisher to put out the flames so you don’t become a bbq burger. Getting across the river to the red blob on the other side and back to the side we came from was no problem. We just spray lots of blue stuff with our extinguishers (it’s spammable) there and back and ignore the mobs till we are safe on either side then dps down whatever follows us. we moved as a group keeping the fire down and healing anyone who was getting beat on while crossing the river.

The issue arises with thekitten npc who is also trying to cross the river. If he were a real person he would have to ride the short bus to school and would probably be walking around with drool hanging out of his mouth stabbing himself in the chest. After we finally managed to get the idiot to the other and discover the blob of orange stuff on the other side we had crossed it back and forth probably 20 times and killed about 10 or 15 of those blobs that take forever to kill. The npc was constantly just standing around in fire and dying while we were all safe out of the fire due to our extinguishers. He seems to try to follow at a long distance which would be fine if there wasn’t lava and fire everywhere but since there is he dies over and over and we have to make multiple trips out to rezz him, escort him over to the other side, then the idiot runs back out to the middle, dies, has to be rezzed again then re-escorted back to the other side. this cycle happened about 20 times – him running out to the middle by himself and standing in fire until he died while were all standing on the banks thinking what an idiot he is.

That npc needs to stay closer to the group and needs to not be so dumb that he keeps running out the middle on his own while were all chilling and drinking corona’s on the other side.

Issue 2
The fight where you have to defend the npc who is building a bomb or working on a bomb or some such and the room fills up with char’s wrecking everyone’s day. After numerous death’s we found a way to get past it but it just seemed cheesy and cheatish. We had 2 people in the room and three people outside the room. The two in the room ran around whacking them and generally staying away from the ones they were whacking around with slows and snares, in the beginning, while the three on the outside stayed out until more spawned. When more spawned one of the three on the outside would pick up one or two and kite them between the room and the hallway on the outside. The mobs will only follow you a short distance outside the room so you shoot them a few times and they follow for about 10 ft then turn around and go to run back in, snare them when they turn back, whack them some more and they come after you again. the three on the outside are constantly pulling two mobs out of the room so thats 6 mobs running back and forth for three players on the outside and 4 mobs chasing our pals on the inside. Its total pandemonium but as long as everyone has thier two mobs we had no problems keeping the bomb repairer/builder alive and getting past the event.

The issue here is that the mobs spawn so fast and have so much health that we just could not dps them down fast enough. Granted most of us are in mish-mash gear as we were all just starting out in explorer’s but even if we were all pimped out in oranges I don’t see how we would have the dps to focus fire them down anyways. They need less health so they can be killed as they spawn. Unless of course this is the way the event is supposed to be done which is possible since there is no door preventing you from running out of the room?

Those are the two issues that we think need to be looked at? Some feedback from Anet would be fantastic if this is “as intended” or if it is inf act a “bug”?

PS… Everyone got 60 tokens for the dungeon so that appears to be working.

LFG for all Dungeon explorer's [Eradon Terrace]

in Guilds

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

With all the speed run farm fixes today, I am hoping some puggers might be more interested in a static pug now?

LFG for all Dungeon explorer's [Eradon Terrace]

in Guilds

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

Maybee a Inspirational pre-recorded video message will get the puggers motivated to clear some dungeons?

Dedicated to Eradon Puggers:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NwwY9y6O3hw

LFG for all Dungeon explorer's [Eradon Terrace]

in Guilds

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

Are there no puggers out there on Eradon sick of spamming for groups?

Messaging Supressed Due to Spamming

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

Messaging Supressed Due to Spamming

in Fractals, Dungeons & Raids

Posted by: Purina.5613

Purina.5613

A channel that can be seen by all levels in all zones and that we can spam our LFG to our hearts content. What a novel idea !

How has this not already been implemented?