Ok, now I had a fully geared 80 mesmer, a nice geared 80 warrior, a fully geared 80 ranger, and a 20 thief. Currently working on thief, future guardian and ele.
For dungeons, I have carefully observed the group contribution of ranger, mesmer, and warrior. With a full zerker build, mesmer(sword/focus) and warrior(gs) deal the most damage, provide great group buff, and have decent survival chance as glassy cannons. Ranger, however, sucks so much because not only feline dies really quick but also the cooldowns on survival skills are just too long. Ramage As One is on of the best dps elite skill(same level as warrior’s elite signet) but there will be no significant damage bonus if my pet is down and swapping pet is on cooldown. With support build, warrior gives decent buffs(banners and shouts) and combo fields(longbow), mesmer apply too many buffs/debuffs(staff) and group ultility(time warp, illusion of life, null field, and feedback that allows me to solo TA spider boss), and ranger… I can’t really think about anything =/ Spirit? Yeah I was on full spirit build for a week and none of my spirit will last more than 30 seconds—even if I placed them properly. No need to mention I have to hide my pet in case it will go aggro some nasty creeps because of its weird movement. So why should I use my ranger on dungeon runs for both my pleasure and my group’s effectiveness?
For PvP, I usually use my mesmer(staff with prec/tough/condi), guardian(healing and condition), warrior(quickness 100b), and thief(dagger storm+stealth skills). I could easily kill any ranger that is the same PvP level as me, and may need to suffer a bit if they are like lvl 40 in PvP(but not often since I believe only few people will use ranger when they are above lvl 20 in PvP. They will usually use warrior, thief, and ele imo). I do use my ranger sometime and found ranger is extremely effective against toughness build engineer, but thats all. Most of the time I will be kitten by mainstream classes(yes, I know how to dodge and when to dodge and what to dodge). One thing I find very interesting is that ranger players usually have some bad temper: /laugh after they killed you or shout out when I continuously quickly kill them for a period of time. So why should I use my ranger not only because the ranger community sucks in some way but also I am getting much better result from other professions? Though I quit PvP like 2 weeks ago cause I don’t like bragging on how many ppl I have killed and how I could “possibly” win the duel between you and me, but on how many ppl I have helped(Queensdale and answering whatever questions or helping skillpoints/heart/vista is what I am talking about).
As for general PvE, this is the only area I like to use my ranger but only on specific tasks like: gathering, getting skillpoints that are heavily guarded, and roaming. I was using my ranger solo farming orr(cause I wasn’t able to tag anything with zerg) till I found out that my warrior could tag almost everything even with a huge zerg(much more effective). So I will use ranger a little bit but thats it.
When come to WvW, I didn’t even touch my ranger after they patch the Guard skill. Thief can eliminate reinforcement, mesmer can do ninja portal, and warrior can mess with anything. Ranger? Heck no.
I believe that some ppl are in love with their ranger no matter how bad the profession is—even defending it by saying they can play it well but I cannot. Please think about you group, you guild, and you server: What advantage have you brought as a ranger? Will the advantage be more significant if you are playing another profession? It is good for you to have some different opinion, but I love my group, my guild, and my server so I want to be more than a ranger.


Have fun.