Guild Wars 2

But you don’t want to spend 15k on a bag??!?!

Earth on Scepter.

I like using two daggers, one to stack 25 Corruption, and one to switch to bursting (which is +6%, not +6). Makes good times.

DR on Karma now too? Interesting. Sounds like DR. I’d wait a while and get back to it. Also, one of the most efficient ways to do karma is by completing fractals at a level lower than your personal level. Assuming of course you’re into fractals

Whether or not the vocal minority exists in the forums or not, the fact remains that the forum is where the feedback comes from. Saying feedback here doesn’t matter because it’s only a small sample of the population is invalid, especially when the development team is literally asking for our feedback here as we speak, in the thread above this one.

1) condition damage/bleed stack

2) RNG based exclusives

3) build viability beyond damage roles

So you don’t think that if a process is accepted as unreasonable that people should give feedback as to why it is unreasonable? I think ANet would like to hear what is not working. I doubt their response would be quite like yours. “Well then don’t do it” is not a good answer. Especially for time restricted content

It’s a complaint because ANet has made it a goal, and one that seems accepted as unreasonable. You seem to be making the case that they designed this bag to prove how irrational it is to work for it. That isn’t the case.

I understand that completely, but as recent developer communication has proved, there is a place for feedback and this is it. Like I said, this is what we have access to, what we have relative power in.

A developer saying “please give constructive feedback in X threads” is a thing that happened recently. If be very surprised and would probably stop coming to the forums if they said “well post here for feedback but since there are so few players posting we won’t really consider it”

When I say most players, I am talking about most that post here. No one can argue that the forums are plagued with negativity.

Obviously the situation is different for content that will remain in the game, but considering you wot always be able to farm candy corn, it’s unreasonable.

I don’t think I’m speaking on behalf of the entire player base, I’m taking examples that are used every day in the forums. And like another poster said, we will either agree or not – all feedback is subjective, but they still ask for it. That’s how collaboration works.

Also, you’re missing the point as Far as the bag is concerned. Rewards should be obtainable by playing the game at a casual pace. Playing the game to get a reward that is specific to this event should be totally possible for people with limited play time without having to go outside of the event and use other methods to acquire it. I don’t think buying candy from the auction house is an acceptable alternative for those that want to gain the rewards by participating in the content, and at current rates, it is unlikely that a casual player will achieve that.

The argument about forums being the vocal minority is not a good one, considering this is where the feedback is. It’s also the feedback that we have access to. We don’t know what data they collect.

As far as using this event as an indicator of collaborative development, you are right -it was a failure on my behalf to recognize time frames.

My argument still stands, though. There are core deficiencies that have been problematic for players from the beginning. Casual friendly is true, and I agree that the most dedicated players should be the most rewarded, but the question is, does accepting the bare minimum in terms of rewards equate to playing the game normally to get what you want?

Aside from rewards, problems such as build effectiveness and viability continue to persist, skill balance is always a topic, time gates are a big issue, and WvW issues pop up often. It’s obvious that any game will have its share of problems but a lot of the ones that fit these categories continuously receive feedback an continuously go unchanged.

Look there’s no reason to get upset, I think I presented my case in a way that provides enough explanation for what I’m trying to convey. Just because you disagree with it doesn’t invalidate it. I understand what you’re saying. Of course the game shouldn’t swing to whatever mood the forums are in.

You also have to realize that there are tons of players who are upset at the direction of the game, an honestly it all goes back to the manifesto – the game’s marketing strategy. People feel cheated because game design that was said to follow through never did.

Now I’m not here to make a case abou the manifesto – take it for what it is. I am however here to point out that there is a lot of similar feedback in the forums about very specific issues that are left unaddressed.

Also, not wanting to farm 10,000 of an item is not being lazy.

Actually this has nothing to do with an individual and the rewards an individual wants. I have everything I was after. What it is, is a critique on the desire for a collaborative process and the talk of certain game design, but the lack of implemented game design reflecting the desire to follow through with collaboration.

I think you’re missing the point.

This is true, and I expect great things from the story, but such a poor reception leaves a bad flavor for the rest of the event.

When posts are made by team members expressing the importance of collaborative design, communication, and constructive feedback, then yes, we are owed something for our feedback.

Has anyone translated the text on the new Halloween shield?

I can’t post right now, but look at the interview with Mattvisual at PAX. Also, the problem isn’t necessarily that cosmetics exist in the gem store, it’s that rewards linked specifically to an ongoing event, especially one as vital as living story, are. My main case is the fact that this year, unless you do insane grind or spend money on Black Lion, you will not have access I hallowed specific rewards. Both methods discourage playing the game traditionally, whereas last year, you could acquire at least three of the skins through playing the game and gathering a reasonable amount of materials.

Also, it is unrealistic to compare GW1 rewards to GW2 rewards.

This is all good. It seems what players want most is the reasoning behind doing what they do, not necessarily for everything to be changed at every disagreement.

I think they add more clutter than normal floaters. The numbers weren’t anywhere near as intrusive as the new colorful graphics.

Does anyone else have a case to make in favor of or against the new Halloween event?

There has been a massive outreach lately by developers in an effort to bring the amount of forum misconduct and abuse to an end. I appreciate the sentiment as I frequent the forums often and try to be helpful when I can, and critical when necessary.

I am not attempting to justify the insanity that takes place here so often, but I think the frustration that evolves into flaming is so evident that current systems in the game need to be looked at. The biggest disappointment as of late is the reward system for the holiday event.

I wrote about this in a post on the Halloween sub, but I want to use it again as it is a great example of current systems not living up to design paradigm.

In a recent interview at PAX, a developer spoke passionately about how they strive to implement anti-grind rewards, and how playing the game at a normal pace should be enough to gain the player the rewards they want.

This halloween event completely shades that line of thought. You cannot receive the new rewards by normally participating in the Halloween event at an even pace, because they are locked in RNG boxes. This is not an attempt to call out the development staff. It is a legitimate question, that, given the tone set in the short segment of the interview, as well as the recent strive for collaborative development, deserves attention so that players can begin to understand the path Guild Wars 2 will continue traveling. -

How do RNG based, gem-store exclusive rewards fit the philosophy of normal play being the most rewarding method of acquisition?

Just keep in mind that all the naysayers are obviously still playing

To answer OP, yes. GW1 costume skin were wildly popular. Towards the end of the game, you were likely to see costumes more often than actual armor. These were direct purchases, no RNG involved.

It’s likely because the game and forums are more populated, simply. Also people now have a bar to compare this event to. I’m sure if last year was the second Halloween event there would be equal dissatisfaction.

Also, the rewards. The weapon skins last year were quite obtainable if you put the effort in. This year they are locked behind fairy tale grinds and RNG. Along with that, the actual story is locked behind achievements rather than being a fun tag-along drama.

Personally, the content is fine. I’m 11/13 on the meta and enjoy the story thus far. The problem is, however, that rather than being a flowing, festive activity, it feels like you have to make a choice in the content you participate in. Do you spend every hour grinding away for an old weapon? Do you break bank looking to get a new weapon? Do you push through the grind fest achievements to progress the story?

There is a separation between the story and the festivities that didn’t exist last year and that’s the only gripe I have with the new holiday. I wonder if the idea to combine living Story with annual holiday events is a bad idea.

Regina Buenaobra.6193:

Greetings!

Julie Nathanson is the voice actor for Tassi.

Here’s a reply on behalf of one of our writers about the Halloween content.

John Ryan, Writer

I also did write the Dead Stop shield inscription. Well, you could say transcribed it from a certain regent cackling over my shoulder.

What’s the translation?

Trying to Join SoloQ and I keep receiving a message telling me GW2 has been updated, please relaunch. Have done it, I’m all patched up. What gives?

Is it only possible to get the door achievement in the Labyrinth this year?

Rachael Augg.2379:

In regards to obtaining the new converted items needed in the crafting: Sonders the Seller will be available to upgrade your materials until Nov 12th.

Can you address this decision?

2g a stack and falling for candy corn

They are. Just give people some time to get them. I have the GS skin and it is able to be sold

No way, look at prices.

Yes

Is this for real? 100,000 materials? No grind, huh? Amazing.

This is absurd, I’m beyond disappointed. I was really looking forward to making that staff this year. Oh well.

Andrax.4576:

Oh thank god i have the gift of souls recipe already and the material requirements for it hasnt changed.
I read the description of the “Tyria’s Best Nougat Centers” and got scared when it said “Used in the creation of Gift of Souls”, so i thought i need them to make the gift.

The original recipes are disabled

Thanks again!

Thanks Durdend, I’m planning on trying out all of these builds soon.

Zelyhn, what traits are you using in your 0/30/0/30/10?

Art/Animation
Developmer communication
Random world dialogue
Jumping(not puzzles, just jumping)
Combat
Sylvari
Asura

It may resurface when Rox/Braham are involved in a living story plot.

Thanks everyone, I’m looking forward to this class.

Lornar’s Pass

Thanks guys, very helpful. I’ll probably be unloading tons of questions here throughout the day while I’m at work. It looks like I won’t be in Water Attunement much in D/F. Am I misreading? Also there seemed to be some disagreement on the viability of Lightning Hammer with D/F. Are there any significant circumstances where it will be desired over Lightning Whip?

Funny I was reading that guide actually while waiting for my post to get some attention. Guess I am on the right track

I’m interested in D/F after reading, it seems fun. I’m going from playing exclusively boring Necro to this Ele, and I was considering crafting to level but then as I read some more I figured I should probably play through so I can learn it a bit. I’ll probably still wind up crafting though.

So as far as I understand the D/F guide, I stay in Air unless I’m blasting/defending/cleansing?

What healing skill is recommended for general play?

Also, how is FGS played? is it auto attack and skills on CD or are there skills that are generally avoided?

The crafting station

I’m leveling an elementalist for PvE (after retiring necro to WvW) and am curious as to the direction I should take. I visit these forums and the class forums regularly to learn.

So at this point a lot of the names I try to make for my characters are taken, and it takes me forever to finally find one. Then, as I am trying, I get “character creation limit exceeded”

Can we get rid of that error? Anyone else have this issue?

Because it was done all through GW1