Where are we supposed to post regarding dungeons, fractals and other non living story related PvE? General discussion already fills with threads at an alarming rate.
General Discussion is correct. With many developers involved in multiple projects, it’s helpful for them to have a main forum to check for input, suggestions, and questions.
Since many more threads will now coexist with others, especially in the General Discussion section, I suggest increasing the amount of threads per page from 30 (to 40? 50?). The threads which go onto the 2nd page are very likely to sink away into the abyss, and the 1st page already has 5 stickies which decreases the amount of visible threads to 25.
This is a very valid suggestion. I had believed that we, as users, could set the number of posts visible on each page, but apparently that’s not the case, at least as I see it in my quick poke on the user’s set-up pages.
The upside: More visibility into threads, especially in busy forums like GW2 Discussion.
The downside: Will it impact load times? I find myself twiddling my fingers waiting for the forums to load at the present time (another argument for new software, perhaps) and I’d hate to wait even longer for loading.
Let me discuss with my team and we’ll see what we can do.
Thanks for the suggestion.
Does that mean that the following will be deleted or merge?
- Profession Balance
- Crafting
- Black Lion Trading Co
- Dungeons
- etc
I listed subforum that I use. I understand that some subforum are not really active or too specific. But you get from 44 subforums to 24?
I like the addition of an API subforum, but that’s pretty hardcore consolidation.
Yes, those will be part of the Guild Wars 2 Discussion Sub-forum, with the possible exception of BLTC, which may fall in the Bugs Sub-Forum if a forum member is reporting an issue with the Gem Store, a purchased, etc.
This is great news! The number of subforums is excessive imo and this will be more valuable to us and yourselves long term
Thank you! I think over time we’ve developed “forum creep” where we just kept making new forums without thinking of the consequences of that, and of the value in having people involved in fewer forums with a greater cross-section of players.
So what not make it that there are Icons that people select when posting a bug, so when its gets posted it will show via icon for instant notification, so you select Website bug, Forum bug, Game bug, I think this was suggested awhile ago also but it never got any reply, now would be a perfect time to do this, that way you don’t log into that part of the forums and see titles only you will see if its a game/website/forum bugs before even clicking on it.
I think you’re talking about “tagging” a post? If so, with new software, we could do that sort of thing but with the current software we don’t have that sort of technology available.
What about the John Smith sticky? “Questions about the economy” will that end up in general or will it just cease to exist? (Or is it possible for it to lose sticky status?)
Yes, that would be in the Guild Wars 2 Discussion Sub-Forum. I understand your question about making it sticky, but I know we will need to be very particular about how we set up sticky posts, because if we simply left everything stickied and merged, we’d have a full front page of stickies and no new content at all! 
John is a great forum contributor. I’ll talk to him about how we can continue his lively and valuable discussion on the economy. Certainly we want that to continue!
So I get removing Dungeons, and Crafting forums since those features have been officially abandoned by the devs, but why remove the BLTC forum? That is one of the most active forums with one of the most active devs.
First, the Dungeons and Crafting Sub-forums haven’t been abandoned, but it is true that they haven’t seen a lot of dev activity lately. Our hope is that when we’re asking the developers to look at fewer forums — to not have to scroll down 11 times to get to the bottom group, to not have to play a guessing game of “Where would players look for this info?” — there will be increased developer participation.
As far as the BLTC — that’s a good point, but I think we need to stay on this path for now. I will talk to the team member who have been active in BLTC and Gem Store discussions and ask them to look for posts on “their” topics in GW2 Discussion. Their feedback will help us make any adjustments that are truly required to increase our responsiveness all around.