Guild Wars 2

DONT YOU DARE RUIN THIS FOR ME!!

its not a bug its a feature
just did fractal t4 + cm100 ..and i had a blast

sometimes i like being a little bit sardistic and.. blowing our druid up with ten condis tickign thousands of damage with no warnign gave the shickles every time.. sure i died quite often as well.. but i had more fun than on any prior run this past week..

pls.. let this in the game

also it does make sense i mean.. epedemics should affect everyone.. kinda?!
or thsoe with weak immunesystems.. who tend to be equally distributed between the teams…

sure it breaks the skill amkes it not useable for normal people.. but i will use it.. more than ever..

just imagien what kidn of mayham i coudl cause at bossfights… MUAHAHHAA

one big problem with team average rating would be duo players how would you calculate 1846rating duoquen with a 426rating? team rating way down to give higher some bonus pts?
other way just make both ratings for calculations equal of the higher rating ie 1846 and 1846 which in return would discourage players to question with anyone below them…. so nothings different from now.. ok you got my vote for team average mmr then…

it’s not about progression as long as you are not improving!

you get rewards byzantium etc the continue on and on
you get reward track rewards

do you really think that a noobcrusher that plays 300games should be platinum not because he’s a good player.. but on the number of games he has played alone????
THAT would create matches with platform players and one reanalysis getting the nob… ggf…
In these last few days ranked matches imo where quite stressful clutch and if in my last few matches which I solo Qued any player would’ve taken part that is the at least top 250.. (in fact at least 4 in one and 5 in the other were top 25) it would’ve been quite obvious to have someone sticking out in these matches

ranking is not for rewards it’s there to generate good matchups and boil.. those were awesome!

sure it doesn’t work perfectly
alt acs.
throwing games deliberately
placement matches
team comp (even though I found this less of a problem this seadon)
are all factors that need some more fine tuning work or rework
but for the love of God don’t argue that one should feel some sort of progression just for participating in games..
that’d be even worse than in seasons 2-4

Lord Hammer Hand.4815:

i kill warrior 1v1 just fine, he might decap me all the time but he dies and i cap back.

ye guardians may not be able to permakite them but except of about 5 warriors I’ve encountered it was either a fight on equal footing or even in my favor

and once you know you face such a warrior you can always switch with a teammate to let him have a nice match up..

still out of all classes I think war needs to be nerfd… but not nearly as much as some people think might be best

I don’t think pvp is dead
to everyone who says that you can only play hot specs… no there are several non hot account’s within the top 250 sure hot is a power increase in most cases.. but that doesn’t mean you can’t make it

build diversity is not really a problem either just look at past esl broadcasts u see 8 teams of 5 players each and a total of 7 maybe 8 different builds

at least today you can play any class semi viable if u want… Gl in the past
surely anet can and should further improve balance … but it is kitten good in comparison to what balance was over the majority of the games lifespan..
hambow.. nothing else..just an example..
who said pp thief isn’t viable.. well it’s certainly not good neither are minion masters… I have seen both this season anyway
and inexperienced players with hot still die to them …
this season I felt only twice that I had absolutely no chance and that was vs thief mesmer placed 1 and 2 the way they snowballed and pressured was just a former of art all other fights I never felt they were unwinnable (now speaking 1 on 1) Dhabi so op .. just don’t step on where u can clearly see he has dropped is reaps kitten ..

I hope I got my point across
I pretty much just +1 forsty and his way of thinking

sorry I don’t know the details either but this is more like a suggestion for anet since A LOT OF PLAYERS are wondering this each season..
why not just add a countdown how many more minutes hours etc the Ranked questions are open then once it’s closed the last few running matches slowly end and then the season is over…

much better imo than having hundreds of players wondering calculating through timezones with potential Date differences or Summer/Winter kittens…

sorry I got carried away… speaking of carrying I played pvp this season….

kitten what did u expect.. more details?
bye

Rodzynald.5897:

Wait wut… 6 wins 4 losses and you got into silver? I had 5 wins 5 losses and got into second or top of the first tier (can’t quite recall now) of gold. How did that happen?

well he was tested off and around silver since that’s what he was last season he wasn’t Convincing enough to be ranked further up

you however got tested against platinum and around players unfortunately only 5 . 5 against them.. but that makes you better than silver…

did you duo que with someone who’s ranking is quite a bit below your ranking?

that would be a great factor

also the more points you have the harder it is to get more and that’s a good thing I’d say

one last thing… with you being high rated and relatively low population in pvp you will get matched with what’s closest to you… when it’s under your rating.. socks for you look at the first problem again..

overall I’d still say that it works as intended
since when players who don’t belong in higher ratings get carried there… there is almost no chance for them to stay up

whilst good players who get mismatched at the start of the season can still work their way up easily

Evan Lesh.3295:

My plan is to set the respawn time to default (15 seconds) plus the maximum amount of bleed time they could have suffered on disconnect. This should be the most fair for everyone. If you accidentally d/c, then you want to get back in as soon as possible.

If there is respawn time left on reconnect, the player will be killed.

I like that idea a lot.
Regarding the stuck in wall issue i might add a when in combat to your idea.

Hey guys,

im pretty close to hitting the daily cap because i havnt really been after them
im still about 31.5k ap so i think i have somethign to say about that..^^

im fine with either keeping the cap or removing daily points alltogether
i want people to be able to catch up to us
because it would be quite discourageing for people who are not max daily ap now because they would basicly never ctahc up..

i love having high ap for some extra karma gold find and magic find..

i also love the idea to slowly increase the daily ap by caping it at about 25% or 50% …hell or even 100% of your permanent aps

that way eliteist players could get their aps higher.. but only if they actually do some achivements

it says i havnt corssed any league divisions for me too

even tho ive reached legendary tier thies season..(once again)

but im quite sure anet wil lfix this (also they can see in your history that you have reached legendary so t should be fine)

i jsut dotn udnerstand why they make it so complicated gettign this achivement..
why not jsut get it aoutomaticly with the legendary reward?..
nah lets boudn it to an extra achivement that tier progresses and gets forgotten to get propper implemented..
i think i have jsut broken english…

anyway i hope the core of my message came across >__<

its a good change for everyone!!

fractal goers can salvage their + 11 and + 12ar infusions into smaller ones
and sicne you can put higher than just mere 7s into armor and weapons you can put in 12 +8 ar infusions and 69s and are at 150ar
which is way cheaper than previously

additionally wvw players can get the infusions they like on everything and every spot that was previously a agony exclusive spot
so more stats and if you want ALL power.. no defensive or offensive…

it took me the first evening to get used to it (so i bought oen potion the first day for my dailys)
but since i figured out how it works.. i love it

well played… “a friend” huh?

am i the only one who is assumign that he bought like 20 skins in the past few weeks now says these kind of thinks so lots of people will buy shild skins since no more new ones will come ino the market and he can sell all his skins for quite a good prize? well
the prize skyrocketed…
as expected..
^_^ (maybe i just think too complicated but id love to see one cheeky kitten tricking greedy players into buying skins so he can get some gold this way )

Nevermore IV

Bring the Acnient Svanir Relic to Rest

as this name already implies i have to bring the ancient svanir relic (that i did have) to rest ( joras statue )
alright…
just that the moment i got that thing (ancient svanir relic) i deleted it because i thought oh great just another trash thingy filling my inventory

then i realized a day later that i would need it…

alright.. went to snowblidn fractal to get the ancient svanir relic and.. didnt get it…
so no ancient svanir relic for me..
(i try this here sicne my original post was deleted and ingame support doesnt respond either)
currently im waiting for a month and i have all the necessarry parts for nevermore (not just the colelction.. alll the parts the moment i get the ancient svnir relic itll take me 2 minutes to bring it to joras statue and craft everything together…)

or.. you just use your mouse.. hover over the mastery point.. left klick it once..then press f.. and wish the downed guy a nice day…

soo i nthe past few days i did tarir meta event a couple of times and EVERY TIME! i got slowed down a lot.
whilst gliding it does not slow down
no idea what it could be.. there is no debuff in my buffbar i DID NOT press the “Walk” key (i tried that and i only walked even slower..)
i am NOT in combat!
and i have a white smoke around my character (like when u are chilled) just that i am not..

it reaally annoys me to get the exalted chests when u walk sooo kitten slow (even with speedbuffs or after the speed mushrooms) you walk a bit faster than withotu them but other palyers without any speedbuffs still outrun you…

it did get removed in character screen one time.. when i jumped in the wate ri still had it but once i was UNDER water it was gone and the third time it simply disappeared somewhat like 15mins after the tarir event (was really fun to walk over the map with this slowed game u really are forced to fight all the creatures.. theres no more running through…xD)

i know thsi problem is not gamebreaking ..but it is so kittening me off that i considered not doing any tarir whatsoever…

i like how once you end up DCd you have quite the high chance to get back into that very same map and keep your participation

it jsut still sucks that if the map gets closed because.. well too less players (like after you did tarir meta lots of people leave and the map wants to shut itself down…)

then the system wants you on another.. more lively map…
id suggest to transfer the participation onto the next map as well (under these circumstances only)
i do understand that you dont want players to farm on one map and still got all the benefits if you then just farm all the tarir metas one after another

but working for participation and then loosing it like that feels kinda bad

Therodin.2970:

I hope sab comes back and will be very happy if it ever does. And they should bring it out as soon as possible because of the ICC or at least refund the ICC. But realistically it is never coming back. There will always be something they want to spend resources on more than sab. Fixing Hot, Living world season 3, next expansion, guild wars 4 (4 will be so great that they skip 3 altogether.).

indeed im so hyped for gw4

soo..
Precursors with skins for each Tier
Tier 1, 2 and 3

i hope its not too late but…
if you work for your precursor.. and can straight up buy the final product…

why not seperate them.. a bit..

like make the account bound precursors have the new skin.. whilst the “old” ones keep their current skin

that way one could (in future) show that they have worked for it..

you cant jsut buy a legendary and get the skins for precursors as well…

which would insentive players to do the legendary journey if they want to collect all (example) sword skins

or does anyone see any disadvantage my idea would have?

i dont think we need a luck eater
we do have some uses for luck like crafting the ram backpack

and i can see mroe to come in the future (hopefully even the ability to drop the essences of luck into our crafting material storage?!?)

but with something liek this

it sounds like anyone who grinded bought or whatevered himself up to 300% base mf isnt just luckier on the dropps which should already be enough.. nah he also gets here and there buffs.. items or anything just liek this?!?

NO bad idea imo

https://www.reddit.com/r/Guildwars2/comments/3jq5va/bring_back_sab_suck_at_love/

its just sooo amazing
this has revived my inner asura

pls anet make SAB 3 make a thing in 2016
(or at least fix the first two worlds..)

hey you players helped to recreate lions arch ..
AND YOU chsoe to name the new place that way

so who do you think is at fault of our cute lion isnt at his spot anymore?
its you
clearly…
right?!?

4. start fixing SAB or at least give us some more hope.. : (

but i get your your idea and yea.. a lot is going on theese days..

just sit on the point

(at least thats what my teammates told me to do)
WTF fight on points!!
what ya doin?!?

etc

well you gotta be carefull
stay far outside the points only go in for the kill
and dont touch the flaming circles of death (no matter of red or blue flames) theyre bad..^^

BrotherBelial.3094:

Obtena.7952:

Funny thing is that no one will need it by the time it ever gets in.

That is true,

Person one “I got my self legendary armor, bye bye Zojja armor!”
Person two “Set to Zurker?”
Person one"yes……"
Person two “so……. That was a wast of gold then”

so.. like legendary weapons are a waste if everyone chooses zerker?
its the skins and the rarity.. (guhahahahaha srry i just cant be serious about it cause legendary eapons are just everywhere.. )

T raw.4658:

Why can’t the offending player pay the remaining player each 10 gold. So everytime u quite its a 40g penalty.

Bet that kitten stops REALLY fast

a really good idea.. just.. that it would kill pvp whenever anet does something that may kick some players will result in players raging and quiting

like currently like 30% of all EU players are getting dcs connection errors or at least heavy lags…

sure punish them

aspirine.6852:

They do look nice, one thing though. Anet could go with another GS look. Most of the gemshop GS look very much the same.

u mean having a hilt stick to a long blade?
..
yup^^

(i understand what u mean… give us more one shard edged greatswords like jotun.. bandit,legionaire,krait,ogre,pirate.. and a lot more… most of them kinda “dirty” and rigged only very few (like belindas) are fine worked and one edged

btw by klicking through the gs skins i found the godskul lgreatsword… thatd look AMAZING with the reaper o.O
(sure its not really fine work and looks more like a brutal slashing horror film..blabla.. but thats exactly what reapers should be like!!!

they are well designed

just dont really fit my taste that well..^^

but ido like big artfull shields liek this one
(on the other hand i dislike this little piece of metal on all the cutting edges on swords dagger and axe)
i think id`d look much better if the metal keeps it together but the sharp edges of that crystal would cut my enemies

i LOVE focus and Hammer though
especially the hammer
anet seems to learn that we want BIG hammerheads and this one.. i might even buy this one..^^

anet please give our permanent salvage kits the option to go into no upgrade chance mode?!?

right click.. enable/disable chance of getting “rare” upgrade components

THAT would buff your ingame items
since the palyers could choose not to fill their inventorys that quickly

btw to those people who say its just 5sec longer at the vendor…
you also have to stop earlier killing stuff and looting because of you inventory is full earlier
also you get more than a few coppers the longer you farm u get blues and greens worth silvers
a few seconds = one kill = more than a few coppers in average
which means more sigils IS a nerf because our inventorys are limited

well.. tyria is a cpompletely seperate world
who knows how dense the air is.. what teq is made of or even how much gravity on tyrias surface has an impact on teqs abitlity to fly..

maybe on our earth something like teq would not be possible to fly
on a different planet however..
its a completely different story

FrozenChinchilla.5249:

Water – Grandmaster trait:
Heals can crit when effecting other players

Opinions?

well with the new system it doesnt have to be a gradnmaster since ull pick one grandmaster and one adept for sure so …

I LOVE THAT IDEA
just switching power and healingpower to determine outgoing healing and allowing it to crit with precision + ferocity possibly further icnrese it would probably resulti n reaaaalllly glassy builds that support and heal like… reversezerkers AND STILL being able to do goods amount of dmg since might will give them flat power onto the ferocity and precision

this would rock (i think) even if some cases could turn out to be a bit tooooo strong
we would see i really like the idea
(maybe grandmaster since this would be build defining would be a good choice as well then switch a bit around but.. yeah)

dear anet pls if u do something like this again (working for your betakeys)
then give us distinct targets
like.. beat vinewrath once and charge the ortal in the ley line cave during sand storm or alternatively do one of the maguuma wastes or dry top reward track
(sure a full track might be too much)
but rng is not what most people seem to like…

Novuake.2691:

eekzie.5640:

I’m throwing money at my screen but nothing is happening.

Try your DVD drive…

Someone needs to test it before I do.

nope didnt worked for me
probly because i dont have a device that would output the remeins…
so i have to guess the right price and insert it there….

dear arena net people

i see a problem in this
due to the limit of mails a account can send within a short time hackers already made it like selling all the items instantly on tp and then send the gold..

now they can do the same and then end up with instabuying reaaallly expensive stuff like precursors

sure this will lower the reward the hacker will end up getting
(reward is the wrong word srry .. but i dont get the word i mean in englisch)
but i doubt this will really solve the problems…
(in fact this will disturb the markets even more than it does already)

i really hope you can add something like

players can mark items in their possesion to
untradeable and unsellable for a few days
so that we can sell it but only after a short time)

ONLY IF WE CHOOSE TO DO SO!!

to not kill traders
that would disturb hackers probably more than your idea would

anyway..^^

lets hope for the best

(btw.. what about SAB? )

i assume we will only be allowed to play the demo
so..
no

but in future events im sure there we will be

i do even think that we are able to play the revenant..however we wont be able to play as we want sicne there will assumingly (if its like the demo) only be celestial a hand full of weapons and 2.5 trait lines to choose from

well see..^^

7k hours tons of ap…
double invitation…
WTH??
please anet take one of mine two (interestingly almost an hour sent apart from another) and give it to anyone here who is willing to play sicne i cant log in with two chras at a time >___<

but heh.. thx and im looking forward to it..

i woul actually like a search function or something where we can sort our characters

some of us (i know first world problems…) who have… “a couple of character slots” sometimes have problems finding the sylvari ranger inbetween the pages of rangers sylvari other classes etc…

porlby not a very high priority.. just saying.. it would be nice^^

i like that idea
i liked the hall of monuments in gw1 and to pick stuff that looks good together

so id prefer about 10 places to put your alts letting them fight against each other in some places (probably just to replace other npcs..)

that would be nice
i wouldnt need access to their inventory but just more customizeable things for it would be nice^^

however there are probably a lot of things much higher on anets priority so.. if it will ever find its way into the game id think itll take about three years…

anyway… i would like it^^

Guhracie.3419:

nGumball.1283:

Delutia Aisyl.9538:

Dear Anet,
SAB has been closed for 15 months now. It’s also been 15 months since I’ve bought Gems. The latter number is going to keep increasing until the former number decreases.

Now think about all the players who will say the same about other features. Also, think about the dozens of players who believe that SAB isn’t series content and a mere waste of time.

You get a community that will never be statisfied which is actually the truth.
We like different things and the company can’t make everyone happy. Therefore they try to balance it up to have an overall positive community while keeping the profit coming in.

They’ve never sold anything on the gem store that was rendered utterly useless for 15 months, other than the infinite continue coin. And then refused to grant any refunds on it. But you keep making your straw man argument that they can’t please everyone. It keeps getting more convincing every single time.

well… there is
revive orb transmutation charges etcetc
u have used them and theyre gone..
surely the infinite coin is still left in our inventory waiting to be used again..
but anet can argue that we got to use the coin.. so surely some used the coin more than others..
like the copper fed salvomatic.. all pay the price some salvage more others less..
but we all did use it.. (probably)

but leaving this aside.. id love to see the SAB opening again (even if it only lets us get into the previous worlds)

suggestion for wintersday 2015
add daily wintersday things to the dailys like:

pvp: get one reward fro mthe wintersday reward track in pvp

pve: (any of these years cycling through from jp over bell choire etc)

wvw: uhm.. i havnt thought so far… hey what about finish.. its also pvp huh?..well u can add finsih people in wvw with a intersday finsiher uhm… gathering is in wvw but shoul not eb daily!^^ is there a wintersday themed buff food? then maybe something like this? i hope u get the general idea to allow players to leisuerly get the meta reward byactively logging in each day andstill doing.. at least a bit of effort into their areas

if they want more than jsut the meta reward
they can go out of their own comfort zone by themselves okay? thanks

well.. u can kill with your bare hands as well…
this makes scythes a bad weapon…
death uses a scythe? noob..

id love the dervich but just like others say a dervish would be an elementalist clone
i mean if we make it a heavy aoe focused class that only has one weapon set… its like an ele…
air and earth prayers on f1 and f2 uh.. elements no class is allowed to use any of the 4elements that belong to the elementalists
sorry warrior but we have to rework your f1 longbow..too much fire…
and hammer f1… thats clearly too much earthshaking…

i think dervishes COULD work
i doubt it will happen
i think scythes look kitten as weapons and i would LOVE them ingame

making all humans into secondary class dervishes by allowing them to transform into their gods avatars (reworking grenth melandru and giving them lysssy dwayna and kormir not just as an minor or healing skill.. racial elites dont have to be overpowered and even if they end up being a bit tooo strong u still can fix it… and theyre not even against your esports pvp..)
on a side note yep this is simmillar to norns who already have a ton of racial elites so theyre all their class and as secondary class… a .. well.. a norn^^ (if they want to do it)

and add for all races more of these elites.. please^^
possibly some order specific elites?
and really.. make asuran elites useable.. other races got at least one elite that can be used at times..^^

what if the scythe in gw1 was aoe weapon insane three targets you could slice up with one swing where usual weapons could only hit ONE target (if not using some other skill that allows you to whirlwindattack or .. u know…)
and in gw2 it becomes a weapon that hits in a semi circle area with a little greater range in front of you up to 10targets?
it would be nice in wvw (watch out for retaliation though..)
maybe a trait that reduces retaliation dmg or something?^^

anyway i hope we will see more races / classes.. but i would not bet on either of it coming soon (if ever)
btw… anyone still in the SAB or Riot fewer? im kinda lonely on my box…

it is possible to squeze a boss fight between the sw phases

be4 the labyrinth was introduced to us
the def phases had just 5minutes between them
so anet could easily expand this time even more

or make labyrinth a requirement for the final boss
or for something else that will be the last seal….

in short.. it IS possible

i was fighting where it came down
it didnt even did dmg it just knocked me away..

if thats all what youve got mordremoth then we weill be having a field day

well besides that your class would be quite similar to a guardian.. sure its not called the same way and a weapon set more but there fore a f4…
these would work kinda simmillar so… mhmh.. probably not

i had a few days ago the idea of aches from gw1 ritualists
so that they would be something compeltely new aoes that are around yourself (like those fire rings in soe (p3 i guess) that damages your allies if u go too clsoe to them

this added with a long cooldown… the ability to drop the asches (similaritys to gw1) to either have a aoe effect.. meh..
or to make it so the aoe will stand at that point instead of continouly following you…

this way the ritualist would get a uniqe set of skills (sure asches should not be the only thing) and that wont be ritualists uniqe class mechanik…

but i guess if anet are planing on adding a ritualist.. they should use the asches from gw1 somehow^^
and pls make them diefferent from guardians consecrations that are always bound to an area u sommon them
and still be different to nature spirits from ranger or warrior banners that can be moved

sure ghosts that the ritualist can summon but… please anet we dont need MORE ai
we already have plenty and if that argument is not viable then how about they are too simmilar to engineer turrets?
kay.. so no ghosts!!^^

11 speak to x laurel merchants
12 forge x items in the mystic toilet
13 win x times costume battle thingy…
14 enter your home instance x times
15 get x luck (u know that one from salvaging blues and greens..)

ok i got a new theory..
he tries not to be seen
and as long as he cant see anyone hes practically invisible….

ok now someone has to jump in and defend him..

always keep in mind that he might be a new player and really did hit 80 mostly by crafting and / or wvw karma train in eotm
because someone told him its the best/fastest whatever way…

and since you unlock the living story steps just like this on 80…

this design thing is what i think will be a problem in the future if anet decides to ramp up the difficulty
(more) newer players will start to struggle more once they unlock their first living world chapter
and because of .. omfg waayy too hard they dont even buy the episodes of the past

that would…
not be good..

ofc be4 anet will be faced with this problem they have to increase the difficulty…
which is still (WAAAYYY TOO) easy if u ask me at least if this is pve endgame content..

the difficult achievements anet wanted to give us..
im still looking for them
jumping on top of the rock in one of the first dry top missions was kinda nice but nothing combat related…
and after this one…
not really many hard to get achievements in the living story besides bugged ones for a few days (im looking at you concordia)

or

hes fighting foefire ghosts
its too easy
to train for some time he goes full hard mode and does it blind
huh?
anyone?
xD

CrashTestAuto.9108:

Piogre.2164:

I would come very close to becoming one of the people on these forums to whom I refer as “speshul snowflakes,” having gotten my storm wizard weapons through sheer blood, sweat, and tears. Then I would take a step back, breath deeply, and be over it.

I’d only get upset in a lasting way if they make this pvp track without also bringing back SAB at the same time- that would be a slap in the face to those of us who really enjoyed it.

I wouldn’t mind others having it, so much as I’d mind the reward structure being ripped out of SAB. Currently, it’s fantastic. Trib mode would still be fun, but it would lose its sense of reward for your efforts, which is a really big part of it.

The current system is fantastic. Blue skins for everyone, so you can still get the “style” if you want it. Coloured skins of the exact same quality for people who take the time to get them. I’m hoping the PvP track gives blues, but not others.

unfortunately we dont know what anes says about this
they havnt even said there will be a reward track..

its all just the speculation what this stormwizard weapon box is all about..
i think its most likely a pvp reward track end chest…
i dont like that idea either …

if we would have datamined more .. like the frog king weapon box ..and probably a third one? … then we could argue that anet just wants to change the way those skins are given to us
(it was kinda strange be4)

it is kinda strange that we only found world twos box..
im probably speculating too much (just because i dont want to accept it is coming as a pvp reward >_<)
but what if this box is just anets beta to test if they can give weaponsskins (also add those almost done existing ones)
or…
something ?..
:(

probly not huh?

cmon i want to hear some speculations from u guys
(into the direction sab not becoming a pvp reward track >___>)

i think a scrap at every 500 step until 9500 then two scraps for every chest until 19500 and so on
this way itd be better than it is currently

AND you also have to see it from anets point of view..
bringing scraps (not full weapons) to the players
either results in mre playing to get more scraps to get the weapon.. or probably some more players buying black lion keys…

i think black lion scraps would work reallly well in that perspective

but i doubt anet will do anything like this (simply because out there are so many players that would deserve the getting the same rewards for doing all these points in the past that it would flood the market with black lion weapons
even if its just a scrap for the first 19 chests.. thats almost 2full weapons for every player with 9500 or more ap …waaaaayyy too many..

surely this is just taken from my suggestion…
but anything more than this.. surely would either be waaaaayyy too crazy
or (if not also given to veterans) will cause in a huge backlash

safest thing anet could do about this is probably to never talk about this… : (