I felt to give some counter arguments to this post. however I do agree that overall DH is only worth taking if you want to go with LB and if you going heavy support with a twist.
I think this is because lets face it: being able to get three full trait lines as a guard was and is everybodies dream. Honor/virtures/valor will be a extremely hard to crack setup either with shouts or meditations.
- Defenders Dogma: Getting a free ‘5th attack’ proc on Virtue of Justice after a block is too niche, and while it may happen in PvE encounters, it won’t happen often and the result of it proccing will be underwhelming.
I think you underestimate what it potentially does. First you will open every fight with a burn attack as soon as your aegis gets removed. Depending on how much damage fire stacks wil cause this will be a huge boost especially combined with Amplified Wrath.
- Piercing Light: This feels like a trait thrown together to appeal to condi builds and to make it seem like traps weren’t shoehorned into the guardian class.
I disagree because basically the whole trait revamp folows the same mechanic. Sigils meditations, shouts all the stuff that boosts a specific type of utility are gethered in one trait (in general the grandmaster). the only reason Piercing Light seems lacking is that it only adds one kind of boost but because of that its an adept trait. If it had more like CD reduction and faster deployment or whatever it had to be a GM trait.
- Hunter’s Determination: I am truly struggling to work out how a brief bit of stability on a ranged weapon skill is useful.. Even assuming you’re in the fray, and that CC is being thrown your way, it comes after a cast-time skill.. which could be interrupted. I don’t like this trait at all, maybe put 2 seconds of stab on cast, and 1 extra per target hit? Though that’s potentially too powerful.
this does make more sense since 3 stacks of s2 stab wouldnt be all that helpful. We have good access to stab already which makes this trait in its current form not worth taking considering the options are far better.
- Dulled Senses: This trait feels like it was implemented purely to synergise with the bad GM trait that knocks back.. as is the guard has minimal knockbacks, certainly not worth traiting for.
this is not true. we have quite a few knockbacks IF line of warding, ring of warding, sanctury counts twords it. Shield 5 is a great knockback as well and this trait also makes protective reviver even better since it adds to securing a rez.
- Hunter’s Fortification: 4 seconds of protection in a TINY radius on virtues.. and it’s a GM trait? This is god awful protection up time tied to important CD’s, it’s only going to trigger passively, nobody would ever pop a virtue for this. Maybe virtue of justice spam on trash mobs would have some nice synergy, but it’s so niche, and requires 2 trait lines.. not even worth humouring. If you want prot uptime, take a hammer, not a GM.
Again this is potentially a awsome trait. Combine it with inspired virtues and indomitable courage your are looking at a 8sec protection, instant pbaoe stab, stun break. and you can reload it while being immune for another time. while blocking all attacks for your whole group in a front arc. I dare this is the strongest defensive combo in the game if abything it might be redundant in itself since one could argue who neets protection behin a guardian with VoC active.
- Heavy Light: Tiny knockback with a sizeable ICD that only applies to ONE weapon.. No thanks. What’s more it’s not even controllable, it could proc at a stupid time that serves you little to no benefit, passive rubbish at its finest.
Yes and no. even if the knockback is small if combined with cripple it leaves enough room to get off another control skill. with a shorter cd this could mean an easy lock down of your opponent.


